The PE firm acquiring Deadspin disregarded internal data showing non-sports content was twice as successful. They instead imposed a rigid, top-down mandate to "stick to sports," revealing a profound disconnect from the actual business model.
Related Insights
The sports media site SportsMole enforced a neutral style guide to maintain consistency. This operational choice backfired by preventing journalists from building personal brands and loyal followings, ultimately hindering traffic growth in a personality-driven market.
As media companies scale, they are increasingly run by finance or legal executives who prioritize pulling business levers over creative vision. This shift creates a market opportunity for smaller, passion-driven companies led by actual creators who are less focused on pure optimization.
Most media companies operate on creative instinct. A more effective model is to treat content and audience growth like a financial portfolio, obsessing over data to predict outcomes and drive decisions. This brings quantitative discipline to a traditionally qualitative field.
NBR eliminated all opinion columns, believing customers shouldn't pay to read someone else's point of view. The strategy is to provide only factual reporting with deep context, empowering subscribers to form their own informed decisions and reinforcing the core value of its high-priced product.
BroBible consciously resisted the industry-wide pivot to SEO-driven "how-to" articles and buying guides. Recognizing they couldn't win by following the crowd, they instead focused on their unique strength: covering cultural figures and the "in-between" stories in sports, which differentiated their brand.
Outside's acquisition of 20+ publications failed because it used a "broad brushed" approach. It ignored the unique cultures, business models, and reader relationships of each title, leading to internal chaos and the founder's departure from his own company, Cycling Tips.
Emanuel asserts that media companies are ill-equipped to own sports leagues because the core operational challenge is managing a fluid, dynamic relationship with athletes (who are often independent contractors). This talent-centric business is fundamentally different from a media company's typical content operations and requires a unique skillset.
Front Office Sports intentionally diversified from 90% reliance on newsletters to a healthier model where newsletters, social media, and events each contribute significantly (roughly 30%, 30%, and 20%). This balanced, multi-pillar revenue strategy makes the business more resilient, scalable, and valuable.
For 20 years, Netflix's identity was built on 'no ads, no live sports, and no big acquisitions.' Its recent reversal on all these fronts to maintain market dominance shows that adapting to new realities is more critical for long-term success than rigidly adhering to foundational principles.
Critics focusing on low social media engagement for The Free Press miss the point of its acquisition by Paramount. Its value lies in the high quality and monetization potential of its niche audience, which can be far greater than that of a larger, more passive, mass-market readership.
