Contrary to market fears of undisciplined spending akin to 'Abenomics', Prime Minister Takaichi's initial policy platform suggests a focus on targeted income redistribution. Policies like a refundable credit tax system and cutting unnecessary subsidies indicate a fiscally neutral or even tighter stance, rather than net fiscal expansion.
Related Insights
Deficit spending acts as a hidden tax via inflation. This tax disproportionately harms those without assets while benefiting the small percentage of the population owning assets like stocks and real estate. Therefore, supporting deficit spending is an active choice to make the rich richer and the poor poorer.
Under 'Sanae-nomics,' Japan's growth strategy is pivoting towards sectors linked to national security. This includes not only defense and heavy industries but also advanced technology like AI, robotics, and quantum computing, as well as energy and food security. These areas are expected to be core beneficiaries of the new administration's industrial policy.
While Sanai Takaichi's past comments raised alarms, her statement that government should be "responsible for both fiscal and monetary policy" is consistent with the BOJ Act's coordination requirement. She has since moderated her tone, suggesting the Bank of Japan's path towards rate hikes will likely continue, driven by inflation data rather than political pressure.
Despite market fears of aggressive "Abenomics 2.0," economist Ayako Fujita argues that Sanai Takaichi's fiscal plans are limited by high inflation. Her proposed policies focus on income redistribution, like tax credits for low-income households, and will take 1-2 years to implement, suggesting a more moderate approach than expected.
Japan's Takahichi administration has adopted a surprisingly expansionary fiscal stance. Instead of allowing the Bank of Japan to hike rates, the government is using fiscal spending to offset inflation's impact on purchasing power. This "high pressure" economic policy is a key driver of the yen's ongoing weakness.
The Nikkei's strength is not primarily driven by expectations of broad fiscal stimulus. Instead, equity investors are betting on the success of PM Takaichi's targeted policies to boost sentiment and spending among middle and lower-income households. This potential consumption recovery is a key upside catalyst that the market has not fully priced in yet.
While Japan's new LDP leadership creates uncertainty, the fragmented political landscape makes it nearly impossible to assemble a large-scale fiscal package, like a consumption tax cut, before year-end. This temporary paralysis actually lowers the immediate risk of fiscally irresponsible policies that investors fear.
The Takaichi government has a political incentive to support the Bank of Japan's monetary normalization. Allowing inflation and yen depreciation to continue unchecked could undermine consumer confidence and her high approval ratings. Therefore, a gradual BOJ rate hike could be seen as a politically astute move to maintain stability and popular support.
Market participants misinterpret PM Takaichi's interventionist stance as a barrier to a Bank of Japan (BOJ) rate hike. However, her top economic priority is fighting inflation. Delaying a hike would accelerate yen depreciation and worsen inflation, making it unlikely she will strongly intervene to prevent a BOJ policy tightening.
A significant perception gap exists between investor groups. Foreign investors largely expect aggressive fiscal expansion from PM Takaichi, viewing her policies as a continuation of Abenomics. In contrast, domestic investors, recalling that the Abe administration actually narrowed deficits, are less concerned about fiscal discipline and have a more nuanced view.