The initiation of the Fed's cutting cycle is the critical trigger for a weaker dollar against EM currencies, outweighing any mixed forward-looking commentary. This is because the cycle's start begins to erode the US carry advantage, a key structural factor supporting EM FX performance.
Emerging market central banks' hawkish commentary while cutting rates reinforces market stability. This low volatility, in turn, gives them confidence to continue the cutting cycle. This feedback loop can make low-volatility periods surprisingly persistent, as the actions and outcomes mutually reinforce each other.
The market believes the Fed is more likely to ease on weak data than tighten on strong data. This perceived asymmetry in its reaction function effectively cuts off the 'negative tail risk' for global growth, making high-yielding emerging market carry trades a particularly favorable strategy in the current environment.
While a stronger growth environment supports EM currencies, it is problematic for low-yielding EM government bonds. Their valuations were based on aggressive local central bank easing cycles which now have less scope to continue, especially with a potentially shallower Fed cutting cycle, making them vulnerable to a correction.
Contrary to conventional wisdom, a rate cut is not automatically negative for a currency. In economies like Sweden or the Eurozone, a cut can be perceived as growth-positive, thereby supporting the currency. This contrasts with situations like New Zealand, where cuts are a response to poor data and are thus currency-negative, highlighting the importance of economic context.
Emerging vs. developed market outperformance typically runs in 7-10 year cycles. The current 14-year cycle of EM underperformance is historically long, suggesting markets are approaching a key inflection point driven by a weakening dollar, cheaper currencies, and accelerating earnings growth off a low base.
While broad emerging market currency indices appear to have stalled, this view is misleading. A deeper look reveals that the "carry theme"—investing in high-yielding currencies funded by low-yielding ones—has fully recovered and continues to perform very strongly, highlighting significant underlying dispersion and opportunity.
The Federal Reserve's dovish stance, combined with a resilient global growth outlook, creates a favorable environment for "pro-cyclical" currencies like the Australian Dollar and Norwegian Krone. This "middle of the dollar smile" scenario suggests betting on currencies sensitive to global economic momentum, not just betting against the dollar.
The Fed's recent hawkish comments are likely a communication strategy to manage market certainty about a December rate cut, rather than a fundamental policy shift. The firm's economist still anticipates a cut, and the market prices in three cuts over 12 months, suggesting the overall easing backdrop remains intact for Emerging Markets.
Stronger US growth isn't hurting EM currencies because growth is also being revised up globally in places like China and Europe. This prevents a repeat of the 'US exceptionalism' theme that typically strengthens the dollar and pressures EM assets, making the current environment less problematic for EMFX.
Instead of directly shorting the US dollar, which can be costly, traders can use the Canadian dollar (CAD) as a more profitable proxy. This approach offers a better "carry" advantage due to interest rate differentials, while still capturing the downside of a weakening USD, especially as the Bank of Canada's policy mirrors the Fed's dovishness.