Gymshark's initial influencer success wasn't a calculated campaign. It was born from genuine fandom; they sent products to YouTubers they personally admired. This authentic, non-transactional approach built real community trust long before influencer marketing became a formalized, paid industry.

Related Insights

Ty Haney, founder of Outdoor Voices, reveals a key community-building step: relinquish brand control. By empowering super fans to host local events, the brand turns them into 'co-owners' of the experience. This generates more authentic engagement and word-of-mouth than centrally-managed marketing ever could.

Instead of using traditional celebrity endorsements, Square's 'See You in the Neighborhood' campaign heroes its actual customers. This approach treats local business owners as influential figures in their own right, lending unparalleled authenticity and relevance to the campaign's storytelling.

When you've built an audience on pure authenticity and haven't yet monetized, the first 'ask' is daunting. The best approach is to 'break the fourth wall.' Create content explicitly asking your community how and if you should monetize. This makes them co-creators in your business, preserving trust.

Instead of spending big on trendy mega-influencers, Gamma found success by scaling relationships with thousands of micro-influencers in niche, high-trust "echo chambers" like education. These smaller, authentic voices spread like wildfire within their communities, driving more effective growth.

The sign of a truly “culty” brand is when customers integrate it into their core identity. A simple test is to ask: would a user proudly display their affiliation with your company in their social media bio? This signifies a shift from a transactional customer relationship to one where users are members and evangelists of a movement.

Birdies founder Bianca Gates argues that real community isn't a marketing tactic. It emerges organically from a founder's genuine need for help, leveraging personal networks for everything from feedback to early sales. This desperation creates authentic early evangelists.

Influencer marketing isn't a standalone channel. Gamma discovered that for every user acquired directly through an influencer, they gained an additional 1.5 users via organic word-of-mouth. This highlights its role as a powerful amplifier for existing organic channels, not just a direct acquisition tool.

A powerful first move for a new brand is leveraging community-driven affiliate platforms. By getting the product into the hands of engaged creators in relevant communities, a brand can build authentic word-of-mouth and generate multi-million dollar revenue before ever investing in traditional CRM or paid media channels.

Gamma’s founder personally onboarded early influencers, walking them through the product and brainstorming hooks. This investment treats influencers as extensions of the team, not just a media buy, fostering genuine understanding and authentic promotion in their own voice.

In a product-led world, the B2B concept of 'founder-led sales' evolves into 'founder-led marketing.' Founders must deeply own the brand's narrative. This means personally onboarding key influencers and being the first to learn how to tell the story broadly, ensuring the message is right before scaling the function.

Authentic Influencer Marketing Isn't a Strategy, It's Fandom | RiffOn