Success in drug discovery hinges on a rare, intuitive 'nose for value.' Lengauer likens this to a star athlete who consistently makes the game-winning shot after many attempts. It's an unteachable gift for getting the big decisions right more often than others, especially in a context of repeated failure.
Related Insights
Elite talent manifests in two primary ways. An individual is either in the top 0.01% on a single dimension (e.g., tenacity, sales), or they possess a rare Venn diagram of skills that don't typically coexist (e.g., a first-rate technologist who is also a first-rate business strategist).
Caltech professor Frances Arnold developed her Nobel-winning "directed evolution" method out of desperation. Realizing her biochemistry knowledge was limited compared to peers using "rational design," she embraced a high-volume, random approach that let the experiment, not her intellect, find the solution.
Genius, whether in comedy, investing, or leadership, is the art of noticing. It's about being more sensitive to details, questioning foundational assumptions (like why slavery ended), and seeing the opportunity in things others accept at face value. This is a trainable skill of curiosity.
Breakthrough drugs aren't always driven by novel biological targets. Major successes like Humira or GLP-1s often succeeded through a superior modality (a humanized antibody) or a contrarian bet on a market (obesity). This shows that business and technical execution can be more critical than being the first to discover a biological mechanism.
In high-stakes fields like pharma, AI's ability to generate more ideas (e.g., drug targets) is less valuable than its ability to aid in decision-making. Physical constraints on experimentation mean you can't test everything. The real need is for tools that help humans evaluate, prioritize, and gain conviction on a few key bets.
Lengauer outlines three models: 'fat' (bureaucratic), 'slim' (reckless), and 'responsible.' The ideal 'responsible' path is the hardest, requiring a 'nose for value' to make constant, difficult judgments about which steps are essential to move forward quickly but safely, without excessive bureaucracy or dangerous corner-cutting.
Solving truly hard problems requires a form of 'arrogance'—an unwavering belief that a solution is possible, even after months or years of failure. This 'can-do' spirit acts as an accelerator, providing the persistence needed to push through challenges where most would give up.
A strong gut feeling or intuition should be treated as a critical decision-making tool. For many entrepreneurs, this intuitive 'knowing' consistently leads to the right choices, even when it contradicts logical analysis, making it a superpower to be trusted and honed.
Experienced VCs may transition from rigid analytical frameworks to an intuitive search for outliers. Instead of asking if a business plan 'makes sense,' they look for unusual qualities that challenge their worldview and hint at massive potential.
The difference between successful and unsuccessful drug hunters isn't intelligence or education, but cultural attributes that exist 'in the margin.' These include radical transparency, honesty, humility, and being part of a supportive, truth-seeking team. These soft skills determine the outcome of high-stakes R&D.