Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Bonson sold Walmart after a 60% one-year gain turned its average 3.5% yield into 1.5%, and sold Broadcom when its yield fell to 1%. He treats historical dividend yield as a valuation metric and sells when a great company's price creates too much opportunity cost.

Related Insights

Instead of reacting emotionally to market swings, investors should pre-establish a specific, data-driven metric that will trigger a decision to sell or reallocate. This strategy, similar to Buffett's, ensures that choices are made from a place of sober analysis rather than fear or greed.

Instead of passively holding an investment, view it as an active choice to buy it at its current price every single day. The decision to sell should be based on a clear analysis of the incremental forward rate of return versus deploying that capital elsewhere.

Bonson personally owns 30 to 35 companies, sizing purchases from 1.5%-2% up to 4%. He says 30 names is plenty diversified and you won't find 80 S&P 500 dividend growers; he sells when the thesis breaks or yield compression creates opportunity cost. He does not go lower because positions must matter.

An investor's peak confidence, when a company has a great team and strong growth, is often the moment of maximum market value. Having the discipline to sell during this 'green light' period, even when it feels counterintuitive, is key to maximizing returns before the market cycle turns.

Bonson calls them accidental high yielders: a 4% yield on a $100 stock becomes 8% when the price halves, even though the $4 payout is unchanged. He wants yield rising from dividend growth, not just a falling stock price, plus qualitative signs like founder ownership aligning management with shareholders.

During periods of low interest rates, investors flock to dividend stocks seeking income. This concentrated buying pressure inflates their valuations relative to fundamentals. Investors who buy during these waves of high demand are purchasing at inflated prices, setting themselves up for significant underperformance when the trend inevitably reverses.

The idea of an infinite holding period is a myth, even for great companies. After Buffett bought Coca-Cola, it eventually traded at 58x earnings in 1998. By not selling, Berkshire endured a meager 4.5% annual return for the next 27 years, proving that even great businesses become sells at exorbitant prices.

Bonson says dividends are cash and 'don't lie,' while EBITDA leaves room for unverifiable growth. He trusts cash in his bank account and watches for slowing dividend growth, which can warn of a cut before management admits it. He says a slowing growth rate may reflect management's own view.

Like a starling leaving a thinning food patch, investors should sell a stock not when it disappoints, but when its marginal rate of return falls below the average of their next best alternative. This applies a simple opportunity cost calculation to avoid emotional selling decisions.

The decision to sell a winning stock should have a higher bar than the decision to buy. High-quality compounders often grow into their valuations or surprise to the upside. Selling a great business like Google, even when it appears optimistically valued, can be a mistake that forfeits future gains.