Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

CareFirst CMO Mack McGee argues NPS is just sentiment. To truly align the organization, they created an 'experience scorecard' blending sentiment with operational metrics like "ID card timeliness" from different departments. This allows non-customer-facing teams to see their direct impact on the customer experience, fostering shared ownership.

Related Insights

To ensure clarity survives handoffs from marketing to service reps, CareFirst invested in overhauling internal service center technology. By reducing the number of screens an employee needed to navigate to answer one question, they improved both the employee and customer experience simultaneously.

CareFirst views internal health as a direct predictor of external customer satisfaction. Challenges identified in employee engagement surveys, such as friction with internal IT systems, are treated as CX risks. The philosophy is that if employees are struggling with their tools, that friction will inevitably be passed on to the customers they serve.

Moving beyond reactive Net Promoter Scores, Airshare implemented a proactive "Customer Health Assessment." This system scores each customer on seven criteria, including flight frequency and relationship strength. This provides an early warning system to identify at-risk accounts before they become dissatisfied.

Metrics like high Net Promoter Scores fail to capture genuine human connection in digital interactions. Instead of chasing vanity KPIs, pharma should seek the "digital equivalent of a smile"—behavioral signals that indicate a truly positive and human customer experience.

The pressure to prove ROI has led CX teams to chase metrics like NPS, which often don't correlate with business results. This focus on "justification" over impact is a core reason CX initiatives fail, becoming a race for a score rather than revenue.

Customer and employee experiences are two sides of the same coin, not separate domains. Beloved brands understand that a disengaged or ill-equipped employee, such as a call center agent lacking proper tools, cannot deliver a positive customer outcome. Success requires treating both as a single, continuous journey.

CIBC drives enterprise-wide focus on customer experience by linking a significant portion of variable compensation for every employee, from the CEO to the frontline, to a 20-metric CX index. This ensures CX is not a siloed function but a shared responsibility.

When AI can directly analyze unstructured feedback and operational data to infer customer sentiment and identify drivers of dissatisfaction, the need to explicitly ask customers through surveys diminishes. The focus can shift from merely measuring metrics like NPS to directly fixing the underlying problems the AI identifies.

To demonstrate value, platform teams must explicitly connect contributions to top-line business metrics. Use internal newsletters to show how a new service directly enabled an uplift in a key metric like Net Promoter Score, making the platform's ROI undeniable.

To ensure customer experience is a priority across the entire organization, Shipt integrated customer sentiment metrics directly into its company-wide OKRs. This operationalizes their commitment to being customer-centric, making CX a shared responsibility and a key measure of strategic success for all teams.

Replace NPS with a Cross-Functional 'Experience Scorecard' to Align Teams | RiffOn