Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

When investing in a structurally declining industry, like the directory business, the winning strategy is to back management that accepts the decline. Avoid teams attempting risky reinventions; instead, favor those focused on maximizing cash flow and returning capital to investors, essentially managing a slow liquidation.

Related Insights

The perception of ATMs as a declining 'sunset' industry creates a valuation discount. However, similar to tobacco, such industries can generate fantastic returns through disciplined capital allocation, even with flat or declining revenue, if the market has overly pessimistic expectations.

If you're over 45 with momentum in a declining industry, a risky late-career pivot may be unwise. The better strategy is often to leverage your experience, maximize earnings, and save aggressively. This allows you to "ride it out" and fund a passion project or an earlier retirement.

While entering a rapidly expanding industry provides a tailwind, skilled entrepreneurs can generate their own demand. The critical mistake is not missing a tailwind, but fighting a headwind by operating in a shrinking market. Simply avoiding a declining industry is sufficient for success.

Companies like the Comcast spin-off Versant are trapped. Their profitable legacy businesses (cable channels) are declining, yet provide the cash needed to invest in an uncertain digital future. This "foot in each canoe" strategy usually fails because they can't abandon the old revenue stream to fully commit to the new one.

Industries widely considered "terrible businesses," like restaurants, often signal opportunity. The high failure rate is usually due to a low barrier to entry and a lack of business acumen among participants. A disciplined, business-first approach in such an environment can create a massive and durable competitive advantage.

In industries such as banking, insurance, and natural resources, management constantly recycles capital. Their skill in capital allocation is more critical to long-term success than the inherent quality of the business itself, as poor decisions quickly destroy value.

John Malone and his circle have historically been trapped by focusing on trailing free cash flow metrics in structurally declining businesses like Discovery and Qurate. This approach is dangerous in telecom and media because high free cash flow can mask underinvestment and an eroding customer base, making it a poor forward-looking indicator.

The company's financial turnaround wasn't about reviving the declining print business. Instead, the strategy was to accept print's structural decline and aggressively grow new revenue streams—like digital subscriptions and events—at a rate that more than offset the legacy losses.

The default that all businesses must scale forever is flawed. Society needs a "death doula for companies"—a framework to help businesses that have fulfilled their mission or become zombies to wind down gracefully. This allows talent and capital to be reallocated to new ventures.

Even a skilled entrepreneur with strong marketing abilities will struggle in a shrinking industry. The constant headwind makes growth an expensive, uphill battle. It's more strategic to simply not fight against a declining market trend than it is to find the fastest-growing one.