Get your free personalized podcast brief
We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.
The US and Japan are not trying to fix the Japanese economy's fundamental problems. Instead, they are artificially propping up the yen to ensure the unwinding of the carry trade is a slow, managed decline rather than a sudden, catastrophic collapse that would devastate the global economy.
Related Insights
Despite official statements against rapid currency depreciation in Japan and Korea, policymakers likely view a weaker currency as a beneficial stimulus. With negative output gaps and competition from China, the goal is not to reverse the trend but to manage its pace to avoid market disorder and US Treasury scrutiny.
The US-Japan yen intervention wasn't about establishing an unbreakable price cap. Instead, its primary goal was psychological: to make speculators nervous about shorting the yen near the 160 JPY/USD level, thereby restoring the Ministry of Finance's perceived threat.
For decades, the US has benefited from investors borrowing cheap Japanese yen to invest in higher-yield US assets (the carry trade). This has created a deep dependency, forcing the US to intervene and prevent Japan from raising its rates, which would cut off the vital flow of liquidity.
The US Treasury's intervention was not just about the Yen's exchange rate or trade balance. A primary motive was to prevent Japan from being forced to sell its vast US Treasury reserves to fund its own intervention, which could create significant pressure on the US bond market.
When the US and Japan intervene to buy yen, savvy investors see it as a desperate measure masking fundamental problems. This perception of rising risk without rising returns drives investment away, creating a feedback loop that can further weaken the currency.
The Bank of Japan's intervention is a defensive measure, not an offensive one. It aims to prevent an explosive, out-of-control yen depreciation (the 'right tail' risk) and buy time, hoping the underlying macro picture (like U.S. yields) eventually changes in its favor.
The US coordinated with Japan on currency intervention not just to support the yen, but as a strategic move to manage US long-term interest rates. The Treasury believes excessive dollar-yen volatility spills over into Japanese Government Bond (JGB) yields, which in turn significantly influences the long end of the US Treasury curve, making yen stability a tool for domestic rate management.
The Treasury's push to help Japan defend the yen is not altruism; it's a strategic move to protect the US bond market. By preventing Japan, the largest holder of US debt, from selling treasuries, the US maintains global demand for its own debt and keeps its borrowing costs low. The support for Japan is merely a convenient side effect.
As investors sell US assets to repay strengthening yen loans, it pulls liquidity from the US system. If this happens slowly, it could gently deflate inflated stock prices without causing a crash. This orderly withdrawal is preferable to a sudden market rupture caused by bursting bubbles.
Japan's decades of low interest rates fueled the 'carry trade,' where investors borrow cheap yen to invest elsewhere. To solve its domestic inflation, Japan must raise rates, but this would cause a chaotic unwinding of the carry trade, threatening global economic stability.