Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Assessing external investment managers requires the same foundational criteria as underwriting an operating company. Allocators must evaluate a firm's market positioning, competitive moats, and the leadership's capacity to inspire, hire top talent, and execute long-term strategic plans.

Related Insights

During due diligence, it's crucial to look beyond returns. Top allocators analyze a manager's decision-making process, not just the outcome. They penalize managers who were “right for the wrong reasons” (luck) and give credit to those who were “wrong for the right reasons” (good process, bad luck).

Many LPs focus solely on backing the 'best people.' However, a manager's chosen strategy and market (the 'neighborhood') is a more critical determinant of success. A brilliant manager playing a difficult game may underperform a good manager in a structurally advantaged area.

Limited Partners (LPs) value fund managers who are willing to listen and internalize market feedback, even if they ultimately follow their own strategy. This openness is a key positive signal, while a refusal to listen is a major red flag that often appears early in the relationship.

When selecting new GPs to back, Brian Singerman uses a powerful heuristic: could this person, playing their own unique game, have beaten him at his peak as a VC? This test cuts through superficial metrics to identify raw, world-class talent, irrespective of their specific investment strategy.

The central task for capital allocators is to identify investment managers with a proven, durable edge—be it in sourcing, operations, or strategy—that allows them to consistently capture alpha in markets that are otherwise becoming more efficient.

Historical returns and DPI are backward-looking indicators lagging reality by five to seven years, offering little predictive value for upcoming technological shifts. Limited partners should instead evaluate prospective VC firms through the 'windshield' by surveying high-performing startup founders on which partners they respect most, particularly those whose term sheets the founders did not accept. A firm lacking partner-level respect among current market builders will struggle.

A powerful, often overlooked, due diligence signal for a fund is the quality of its junior team. Great managers attract, retain, and effectively communicate their vision to top young talent. By networking with peers, investors can gauge if a firm is a talent magnet, which strongly indicates the quality of its leadership and future prospects.

The best investment opportunities are often with managers who have strong demand and don't need any single LP's capital. The allocator's core challenge is proving their value to gain access. Conversely, managers who are too eager to negotiate on terms may be a negative signal of quality or demand.

Instead of focusing on process, allocators should first ask managers fundamental questions like "What do you believe?" and "Why does this work?" to uncover their core investment philosophy. This simple test filters out the majority of firms that lack a deeply held, clearly articulated conviction about their edge.

An effective manager evaluation technique is to recognize that everyone presents their polished "best self" initially. An allocator's primary job during due diligence is to actively investigate beyond this facade to uncover the manager's "true self"—how they operate under pressure and handle failure—before committing capital.