Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Ben Smith's media company, Sema4, intentionally avoids the mass-traffic model that doomed BuzzFeed. By targeting a niche, high-value audience, it achieves profitability through large-scale events and focused advertising, proving smaller, targeted reach can be more lucrative.

Related Insights

Legacy media companies are bloated with high costs and outdated revenue models. The opportunity now lies with lean, creator-led brands that operate with low overhead and leverage built-in distribution to niche audiences. These new media businesses can be highly profitable, with small teams pocketing seven figures.

The old digital media strategy of rapid scaling via social platforms failed because those audiences were not truly owned. They belonged to Google and Facebook, exhibiting no loyalty to the media brand itself. The new focus is on building direct, dedicated audiences.

Sema4 prioritized its "convening" (events) business at launch because it can be monetized and scaled to profitability faster than a digital ad business, which requires a long-term audience build-out. This strategy provides a stable revenue base from day one.

The newsletter's founders intentionally resist expansion, avoiding the investor-driven pressure for scale that often compromises creative products. By focusing on a model that makes them happy and serves their existing audience, they've built a sustainable, highly profitable business without chasing growth for its own sake.

In the mid-2010s, VC-backed media like BuzzFeed operated under a "growth at all costs" mandate where achieving profitability was seen as a failure to spend enough on expansion. This created an unsustainable competitive landscape for privately-owned, profit-focused businesses that couldn't afford to "sell $1 for 50 cents."

Contrary to the view that events are difficult and not scalable, Semafor's CEO considers them one of the highest-margin businesses adjacent to quality journalism. He is pleased when competitors dismiss events, viewing their skepticism as a competitive advantage that leaves a profitable market open.

After experiencing BuzzFeed's hyper-growth phase, Ben Smith champions a radically slow hiring process. He jokes his goal is to "never hire," focusing only on adding individuals who make a huge impact. He believes the old model of competing with a "cast of thousands" is ineffective for modern journalism.

Social media platforms are algorithmically incentivizing creators to become "micro giants" (1-5M subscribers) with highly engaged niche audiences, rather than global superstars. This model is more sustainable and allows for direct monetization with targeted products, representing a strategic shift in the creator economy.

Technology has dramatically lowered content production and distribution costs. This allows individual creators and small teams to build profitable media brands that can outmaneuver traditional media companies burdened by high overhead and outdated cost structures.

Lerer advises against the venture-backed media model of chasing massive scale. Broadening the user base to justify valuations dilutes the product, kills the joy of creation, and forces an unwinnable fight against big tech platforms for ad revenue. Profitability at a smaller, passionate scale is the better path.