The ELEGANT trial enrolls all high-risk ER-positive patients, not just those with ESR1 mutations. The rationale is that unlike in metastatic disease, early breast cancer is fundamentally ER-driven. Elicestrin targets both wild-type and mutant ER, making the mutation status less critical for efficacy in this earlier setting.
Related Insights
Cancers with estrogen receptor (ER) expression of 50% or less, while technically HR+, often behave biologically like basal or triple-negative tumors. These cancers are not primarily endocrine-driven and show a significant benefit from the addition of immune checkpoint inhibitors, challenging traditional subtype classifications.
ctDNA testing (liquid biopsy) is more effective than tissue biopsy for identifying ESR1 mutations. It samples DNA from all metastatic sites, capturing the disease's genetic heterogeneity and reflecting the most active resistance mechanisms, unlike a single-site needle biopsy which can miss them.
The SERENA-6 trial showed improved survival by switching therapy upon ctDNA detection of ESR1 mutations. However, it required screening over 3,300 patients to randomize just 315, highlighting the immense scale, cost, and patient drop-off of applying this serial monitoring strategy in standard clinical practice.
ESR1 mutations in breast cancer are acquired alterations, meaning they can be missed by a single test. The speaker advocates for serial testing, especially after disease progression, using blood-based ctDNA analysis. This dynamic monitoring approach is essential for identifying patients who become eligible for targeted therapies over time.
The ELEGANT trial uses a "switch strategy," introducing elicestrin only after 2-5 years of standard therapy. This design pragmatically adapts to the evolving clinical landscape where CDK4/6 inhibitors are now standard initial treatment, ensuring the trial's relevance by testing the drug in a post-CDK4/6 inhibitor setting.
Cellcuity is pursuing FDA approval first in a difficult-to-treat 'wild-type' breast cancer population. Data for the 'mutant' cohort is timed to support a supplemental filing post-approval, creating a strategic, sequential path to capture the entire market while getting to market faster.
Not all mutations are equal. PIK3CA alterations are often present from the start (truncal mutations), indicating a more aggressive cancer. In contrast, ESR1 mutations are typically acquired later as a direct mechanism of resistance to endocrine therapy, making repeat testing after disease progression crucial.
By targeting the integrin Alpha V Beta 6, found in nearly 100% of patient samples for major carcinomas, Accession simplifies its clinical trials. For its first trial across six indications, the company can enroll "all comers" without the costly and time-consuming step of pre-screening patients for the target.
Post-approval studies of the oral SERD elacestrant confirm its clinical benefit in ESR1-mutant breast cancer. However, this real-world evidence also reveals a new insight: patients who have both an ESR1 and a PIK3CA mutation tend to have a shorter time on treatment, suggesting that the PIK3CA mutation may drive resistance to this therapy.
Cellcuity's drug is effective in breast cancer patients without PIK3CA mutations (wild type). This challenges the dominant precision medicine model that requires a specific genetic marker, showing that a pathway's aberrant activity can be a sufficient therapeutic target on its own.