The official cause of Tchaikovsky's death—cholera from unboiled water—is often rejected in favor of suicide conspiracies. This reflects a cultural discomfort with a celebrated artist dying from a mundane disease, preferring a narrative that aligns with the romanticized image of a tortured genius.
While Tchaikovsky was a fervent Russian patriot, his focus on folk traditions and national identity was part of a wider 19th-century European Romantic movement. His 'Russianness,' far from being unique, was an expression of a continental trend celebrating national character in art.
Despite harsh laws, homosexuality in 19th-century Russia was often viewed as a personal taste rather than a defining identity. For wealthy, connected individuals like Tchaikovsky, this perception meant the risk of prosecution or public scandal was minimal, allowing for a relatively open secret life.
Feeling the pressure of social convention, Tchaikovsky impulsively proposed to a woman he barely knew. His immediate and profound regret—marked by bursting into tears at the wedding and fleeing the marriage—demonstrates a tragic conflict between his personal reality and the societal duty he felt compelled to perform.
For middle-class Russians like Tchaikovsky, music was not a respectable profession. The primary path to social standing was a prestigious and hard-to-attain role as a civil servant, a career he pursued for years before his father encouraged him to switch to music.
Posthumous narratives of Tchaikovsky's life reflect the biases of later eras. Soviet historians actively erased evidence of his homosexuality to fit a state-sanctioned image, while Western scholars often over-emphasized it, framing him as a tortured 'gay composer' to fit their own cultural narratives.
Tsar Alexander III, promoting an ideology of Russian exceptionalism, used Tchaikovsky's work for political ends. By celebrating him as a distinctly 'Russian' composer and bestowing state honors, the regime transformed his art into a tool for advancing a nationalist agenda of cultural separation from Western Europe.