Private firms like ADP have business incentives that may conflict with the public's need for consistent economic data. ADP's recent decision to stop providing weekly data to the Fed during a government shutdown highlights this tension and the irreplaceability of official government statistics.
Despite progress on shelter inflation, core services excluding shelter (the "super core") remain sticky. This persistence, linked to wage components, is a primary reason the Federal Reserve will likely pursue a gradual pace of interest rate cuts rather than a more aggressive easing policy.
The most significant danger of a prolonged government shutdown is the disruption to federal statistics. This creates an "unsettling" lack of visibility for policymakers, potentially causing them to miss a critical economic downturn and delay a necessary response. The direct GDP impact is often recoverable later.
The current labor market is characterized by both low hiring and low firing rates. While this appears stable, it makes the economy fragile and more vulnerable to negative shocks. Unlike a high-churn environment, there is little buffer to absorb a sudden downturn, increasing the risk of a rapid deterioration.
The primary economic concern is not a cyclical recession but a structural slowdown in the economy's underlying trend growth. This is driven by long-term factors like restrictive immigration policies that impact labor supply and productivity, creating a persistent headwind even without a formal downturn.
A key but overlooked issue with the Consumer Price Index (CPI) is the deteriorating quality of data imputation. An increasing percentage of missing data points are being filled using less-similar items ("different cell" imputation). This degradation in methodology introduces a hidden risk to the reliability of the headline inflation numbers.
The tangible economic effect of the AI boom is currently concentrated in physical capital investment, such as data centers and software, rather than widespread changes in labor productivity or employment. A potential market correction would thus directly threaten this investment-led growth.
Beyond immediate labor supply issues, restrictive immigration policies, such as for H-1B visas and students, could have pernicious, long-term negative effects on US productivity. By limiting access to high-skilled talent, these policies threaten the country's technological edge and overall trend growth.