/
© 2026 RiffOn. All rights reserved.
  1. Product Rebels
  2. From Consensus to Conviction
From Consensus to Conviction

From Consensus to Conviction

Product Rebels · Feb 12, 2026

Product leader Timothy Alvis on why conviction beats consensus, storytelling trumps data, and focusing on the right problem is key to success.

Pitch Product Ideas by Starting With the Climax to Immediately Engage Stakeholders

Instead of a traditional story structure, present the most exciting outcome first. This immediately creates either allies who want to believe or skeptics who want to challenge you. Both states are preferable to apathy, as an engaged audience is a listening one.

From Consensus to Conviction thumbnail

From Consensus to Conviction

Product Rebels·7 days ago

Aspiring Product Leaders Should Prioritize Developing Judgment Over Mastering Frameworks

It is easy to confuse process mastery with product success. The most critical skill is judgment—the ability to identify what truly creates customer value. This is proven not by your process, but by the ultimate business outcome: customers paying with their time or money.

From Consensus to Conviction thumbnail

From Consensus to Conviction

Product Rebels·7 days ago

Unify Acquired Teams by Focusing on the Shared Customer Problem, Not Competing Solutions

During M&A integration, conflict arises when teams defend their respective solutions. Re-center the conversation on the customer problem they both aimed to solve. Emphasizing that all solutions are temporary and fungible de-escalates conflict and fosters alignment around a shared, permanent goal.

From Consensus to Conviction thumbnail

From Consensus to Conviction

Product Rebels·7 days ago

A Product Organization's True Maturity Is Measured by the Speed of Its Learning Cycle

Forget frameworks and documentation types; they are vanity metrics. The single most important measure of a product organization's effectiveness is its learning velocity—how quickly it can gain an insight and act upon it. A daily cycle is world-class; a monthly cycle indicates immaturity.

From Consensus to Conviction thumbnail

From Consensus to Conviction

Product Rebels·7 days ago

A Compelling Narrative With Weaker Data Will Beat Strong Data With a Poor Story

In high-stakes product decisions, data alone is insufficient to persuade senior leaders. A compelling narrative that taps into emotions and vision is more effective. The better story, even with less supporting data, will often win against a data-dump because decisions are both rational and emotional.

From Consensus to Conviction thumbnail

From Consensus to Conviction

Product Rebels·7 days ago

Fully Committing to a Bad Decision Gathers the Best Evidence for Its Failure

Actively supporting a decision you disagree with isn't just about team cohesion. If the project fails despite your best efforts, you have collected the most credible data to prove the initial decision was wrong, which is far more convincing than if you had undermined it from the start.

From Consensus to Conviction thumbnail

From Consensus to Conviction

Product Rebels·7 days ago

A Product Manager's Goal Is Customer Understanding, Not Filling the Engineering Backlog

PMs often feel pressure to keep engineers busy building new features. The real job is to drive deep understanding, even if it means perfecting three core features rather than adding a fourth. It's better to pause building than to create a bloated, mediocre product that does nothing well.

From Consensus to Conviction thumbnail

From Consensus to Conviction

Product Rebels·7 days ago

Product Managers Should Schedule Technical Debt Pay-Down as a Strategic Feature

Don't let technical debt accumulate until it cripples your ability to innovate. Product should proactively treat it as a feature to be prioritized. Use natural lulls in the product cycle to pay down debt, ensuring you can move fast when the next big market opportunity arises.

From Consensus to Conviction thumbnail

From Consensus to Conviction

Product Rebels·7 days ago