When Slack launched a competing feature, Polly realized being a single-platform app was an existential threat. They survived by expanding to Teams, Zoom, and Google Meet, transforming from a 'Slack poll app' into a multi-surface engagement platform, thereby de-risking their business.
Despite a clunky, multi-screen setup requiring users to copy and paste API tokens, 80% of early adopters completed the process. This incredible tolerance for friction was an undeniable signal that they were solving a desperate need in the market.
Instead of trying to monetize every user, Polly strategically views casual, free creators as 'pollinators.' These users introduce the app into an organization and distribute it widely. This creates top-of-funnel awareness which eventually puts the product in front of high-value 'flowers' (buyers) who will pay.
As a freemium product with millions of users, Polly struggled to identify its true buyers. By adding simple "book a demo" links and feedback request emails into the onboarding flow, they generated hundreds of valuable conversations that clarified their monetization path and ideal customer profile.
For Polly's horizontal product, the founder learned the most critical mistake was assuming every user should be a paying user. The key to success was distinguishing the vast user base from the specific buyer persona, a trivial-sounding but fundamental insight that guided their entire strategy.
Polly's core viral loop wasn't just about initial adoption. They discovered that 12% of users who first interacted with the product by responding to a poll would then become creators themselves, creating a compounding, multi-generational growth engine within organizations.
The company's first paying customer was using the product for a casual fantasy football league. However, this user loved the product so much he recommended it to his HR team, revealing a high-value enterprise use case the founders hadn't initially targeted.
After realizing most users creating casual polls for lunch spots would never pay, Polly found its premium market. They targeted users responsible for expensive, high-stakes events like company all-hands and sales kickoffs, where the value of instant feedback was undeniable and justified the cost.