Amanda Natividad says if links kill reach and clicks are hidden, marketers must return to impressions. She tests this on LinkedIn and gets at least three, sometimes nine, times the reach without a link, then aims to deliver value so prospects remember and trust her until they buy.
Amanda Natividad suggests naming a real aspirational customer—her example is Sam Altman—and studying what that person shares and comments on. That gives the whole team a concrete target for content decisions instead of arguing internally and abstractly about thought leadership or zero-click content.
Amanda Natividad recalls Rand Fishkin following her back and realizing he did not need basic marketing advice. He would be curious about her approach and tests—things only she can describe from having lived them. That clarified the content only she is positioned to make.
Daniel Murray says if he is bored writing a piece, he cannot publish it and expect others to care. Amanda Natividad agrees that passion shows through, and that broad high-volume keywords like “email marketing” are not enough—you need a specific point or question that interests you.
Daniel Murray warns that every weak post is a negative signal that can turn off future buyers, an “audience LTV” cost. Amanda Natividad adds that mediocre posts also train algorithms not to serve your content, so three great posts beat five meh posts in a week.
Amanda Natividad says if a thousand-word blog post can yield three to five LinkedIn pieces, it probably contains a worthwhile idea. If there is only one post in it, that is a warning. She uses repurposeability and discussion quality as early qualitative KPIs before click data arrives.
Amanda Natividad cites platform changes: Twitter codes link posts as a spam vector, LinkedIn prioritizes posts without links, and Meta reported 97.3% of high-reach Facebook posts lack links. She also says TikTok clicks show as direct traffic, so even successful link clicks can be invisible in analytics.
Amanda Natividad says taste comes from practice in curation and creation. She recommends asking why a piece is relatable, smart, or funny—specifically whether it reveals an emotional truth—instead of accepting “I just like it.” That turns passive consumption into a feedback loop for making better content.
Amanda Natividad recalls describing her heuristic as “zero click value” while talking with Rand Fishkin, who told her to blog it. She had been focused on growing her own social accounts at the time. The phrase spread because it named behavior marketers already recognized, even though the term emerged from a spontaneous conversation.
Daniel Murray reverse-engineers the ideal comment or DM share before posting. Amanda Natividad agrees and says amplification is usually status signaling—people comment or reshare to look smart, funny, or in-group. So content should be built deliberately for the reaction it is meant to trigger.
Amanda Natividad says Instagram activity happens mostly in DMs and stories, so posts should earn a share, while LinkedIn is better for comments and likes. She says different platforms let you track different reactions, so the content and measurement should match the native action on each platform.
Amanda Natividad recommends making a minimum viable version of a big idea—for example, ask to send one newsletter before proposing a weekly cadence. She notes you can always stop if it fails, and one reasonable KPI is early enough to learn whether to continue.
