The EM FX risk appetite index, which has a strong track record of predicting downturns, is at an extreme level, suggesting a correction. However, the model was trained during a dollar-bullish cycle and may be misinterpreting the current pro-cyclical, bearish-dollar environment, potentially making its contrarian signal less reliable this time.

The danger to the U.S. dollar is not a dramatic replacement by the Euro or RMB, but a slow erosion of its primacy. This is visible in central banks increasing gold reserves, greater hedging activity, and China’s de-dollarization campaign. This gradual shift ultimately raises borrowing costs for the US government and American consumers.

The dollar's decline, particularly in April, was not driven by investors divesting from US assets. Instead, it was caused by investors with large, unhedged dollar exposures belatedly adding hedges. This involves selling dollars in the spot or forward markets, creating downward pressure without actual asset sales.

Unlike emerging markets where pro-cyclical trades are crowded, positioning data shows the bearish US dollar view is not widely held in G10 currencies. This lack of a broad consensus short means there is less risk of a sharp deleveraging, giving pro-cyclical G10 FX more room to appreciate against the dollar.

With dollar correlations at elevated levels, finding cheap, clean directional expressions against the dollar is challenging. Sophisticated traders are creating bearish dollar baskets that mix G10 currencies (AUD, NOK) with Emerging Market currencies (HUF, ZAR) to achieve greater pricing efficiency.

The U.S. dollar's decline is forecast to persist into H1 2026, driven by more than just policy shifts. As U.S. interest rate advantages narrow relative to the rest of the world, hedging costs for foreign investors decrease. This provides a greater incentive for investors to hedge their currency exposure, leading to increased dollar selling.

While broad emerging market currency indices appear to have stalled, this view is misleading. A deeper look reveals that the "carry theme"—investing in high-yielding currencies funded by low-yielding ones—has fully recovered and continues to perform very strongly, highlighting significant underlying dispersion and opportunity.

The combination of restrictive trade policy, locked-in fiscal spending, and a Federal Reserve prioritizing growth over inflation control creates a durable trend toward a weaker U.S. dollar. This environment also suggests longer-term bond yields will remain elevated.

According to Keith McCullough, historical backtesting reveals the rate of change of the U.S. dollar index is the most critical macro factor for predicting performance across asset classes. Getting the dollar right provides a significant edge in forecasting moves in commodities, equities, and other global markets.