Wagner found a derivative in an Asian market trading at 10-20% of its intrinsic value. This extreme mispricing is a direct result of huge, persistent, and structural shorting demand from quant funds and pod shops, creating a rare asymmetric opportunity for those willing to take the other side.

Related Insights

The firm discovered a reversal effect in stocks down 70-80%. The strategy's efficacy was confirmed when their own traders instinctively wanted to override these trades due to negative headlines. This emotional bias, even among professionals, is the inefficiency the model exploits.

Speculation is often maligned as mere gambling, but it is a critical component for price discovery, liquidity, and risk transfer in any healthy financial market. Without speculators, markets would be inefficient. Prediction markets are an explicit tool to harness this power for accurate forecasting.

Despite its theoretical role as a market check, short selling is often a tool to create chaos and innuendo for profit. Activist short-sellers release reports to move markets for their own gain, which rarely uncovers true malfeasance and is an extremely difficult way to consistently make money. It's more about creating narratives than finding fraud.

Contrary to popular belief, the market may be getting less efficient. The dominance of indexing, quant funds, and multi-manager pods—all with short time horizons—creates dislocations. This leaves opportunities for long-term investors to buy valuable assets that are neglected because their path to value creation is uncertain.

In the world of hyper-short-term pod shops, a stock being "cheap" is a sign of a broken thesis, not a value opportunity. This highlights a fundamental philosophical divide where traditional value investors see opportunity, while pods see a reason to sell immediately.

The venture capital paradigm has inverted. Historically, private companies traded at an "illiquidity discount" to their public counterparts. Now, for elite companies, there is an "access premium" where investors pay more for private shares due to scarcity and hype. This makes staying private longer more attractive.

Financial models struggle to project sustained high growth rates (>30% YoY). Analysts naturally revert to the mean, causing them to undervalue companies that defy this and maintain high growth for years, creating an opportunity for investors who spot this persistence.

Instead of trying to have a view on everything, Herb Wagner's team embraces not knowing. They actively avoid complex situations, like Chinese property developers, where risks are opaque and dependent on government action. This discipline of knowing what you don't know is central to their strategy.

The dominance of passive funds and hyper-short-term pod shops has doubled the average stock price movement in the REIT space. This increased volatility creates opportunities for long-term investors to capitalize on exaggerated market reactions to minor news.

Following events like Hurricane Ian, the reinsurance market has repriced risk dramatically. Wagner explains that a risk historically priced to pay out 15-20% (implying a ~1-in-6 year event) is now priced to pay out over 50% (implying a 1-in-2 year event), creating a significant opportunity from the dislocation.

Massive Short Demand from Pod Shops Creates an Asian Derivative Trading at a 90% Discount | RiffOn