Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Cubillos says Wunderkind's data shows two-thirds of shoppers do not rank discount as their top purchase driver, and discounts stopped driving BFCM conversions. She points to Sephora's staggered sale openings and recommends tiered access for loyalty members, repeat buyers, high-AOV customers, recent browsers and SMS subscribers—each segment gets a unique hour.

Related Insights

Instead of just a discount, companies like Magic Mind and AG1 boost conversions by bundling 'welcome gifts' like digital products or exclusive merch. This creates a unique, limited-time value that a simple percentage off cannot replicate, effectively sweetening the deal for customers.

Instead of offering direct discounts, which can devalue products, consider a double or triple loyalty point event. This strategy incentivizes customers to spend more to earn future rewards, effectively driving sales while encouraging repeat visits and fostering long-term loyalty. It costs little while giving customers a strong incentive.

Create extreme urgency by offering a high discount for a very short window (e.g., 30 minutes), then progressively lower discounts for subsequent time blocks. This gamified approach forces immediate purchase decisions by making customers feel they will lose out on the best deal if they wait.

Consumers are no longer a monolith; they simultaneously seek deals, reduce spending, or pay a premium for specific items. Single-path strategies will fail. Retailers must adopt scenario-based planning to cater to these diverse and often conflicting behaviors when planning inventory, pricing, and messaging.

Traditional loyalty programs often attract one-time discount buyers, not true brand advocates. A 'disloyalty' program identifies and excludes these unprofitable segments from advertising. This saves significant ad spend, improves conversion rates, and helps focus efforts on truly loyal customers.

For the first time, Coach led its Black Friday and holiday season with brand messaging, not promotions. This reflects a conviction that building genuine brand desire reduces the need to compromise on price, even during peak sales periods, thus protecting brand value.

BFCM customers buy on discount, not brand affinity, and rarely return. Brands must go overboard with post-purchase brand storytelling through multiple channels (email, ads, social) to reinforce the "why" and earn a second purchase from this transactional cohort.

Instead of offering a standard discount to all abandoning shoppers, AI analyzes individual behavior to determine the precise, minimum percentage off needed to secure the conversion. This maximizes sales while preventing unnecessary margin erosion.

Cubillos says 40% of holiday shoppers intentionally abandon carts to trigger discount emails, and more than 53% of consumers are dormant during Black Friday and Cyber Monday. Instead of adding discounts, Wunderkind advises brands to withhold the clock—using timed access, staggered releases of top SKUs and FOMO—so audiences stop waiting for markdowns.

A brand called Set Active created a campaign with a 25% discount for only 30 minutes, which then dropped to 20% for the next 30, and finally 15% for the rest of the day. This tiered scarcity model compels immediate purchases by creating a fear of missing out on the best deal.