Despite strong Q3 revenue surprises suggesting a recovery, the Federal Reserve's reluctance to cut rates aggressively is preventing a market expansion into smaller-cap and lower-quality cyclical stocks. The market needs a clearer dovish signal before this rotation can occur.
Despite progress on shelter inflation, core services excluding shelter (the "super core") remain sticky. This persistence, linked to wage components, is a primary reason the Federal Reserve will likely pursue a gradual pace of interest rate cuts rather than a more aggressive easing policy.
The Federal Reserve is tightening policy just as forward-looking inflation indicators are pointing towards a significant decline. This pro-cyclical move, reacting to lagging data from a peak inflation print, is a "classic Fed error" that unnecessarily tightens financial conditions and risks derailing the economy.
Recent inflation was primarily driven by fiscal spending, not the bank-lending credit booms of the 1970s. The Fed’s main tool—raising interest rates—is designed to curb bank lending. This creates a mismatch where the Fed is slowing the private sector to counteract a problem created by the public sector.
The Fed is behind its usual schedule for easing policy due to data delays and COVID-era distortions. This has suppressed the typical market rotation but means the eventual dovish policy will likely be stronger than expected, creating significant upside for early-cycle investments.
The market is interpreting stable economic growth paired with only modest Federal Reserve rate cuts as a clear signal to maintain leadership in high-quality stocks. A broad rotation into deep cyclical and small-cap stocks is unlikely until the Fed becomes more aggressively dovish.
With the Federal Reserve signaling a market backstop, capital is flowing from concentrated large-cap tech winners into more cyclical, under-loved small-cap stocks (IWM). This support de-risks 'Main Street' sectors and signals a potential broadening of the market rally.
Investors should wait for two specific triggers before increasing small-cap stock exposure. The first is the Fed Funds rate falling below the 2-year Treasury yield. The second is a clear upturn in the relative earnings revision breadth of small-cap versus large-cap companies.
Following a dovish Fed meeting, the outperformance of small-cap stocks (IWM ETF) versus large-cap tech is the key signal of a healthy, broadening market rally. This indicates capital is flowing beyond mega-cap names into the wider economy, confirming a "game on" sentiment for risk assets.
The split vote on rate cuts (hawkish vs. dovish) is not merely internal politics. It reflects a fundamental tension between strong consumer activity and AI spending versus a weakening labor market. Future policy hinges on which of these trends dominates.
The market is entering an early-cycle earnings recovery, signaling a new bull market. This environment, supported by anticipated Fed rate cuts and favorable growth policies, is expected to benefit a wider range of companies beyond large-cap tech. Consequently, strategists have upgraded small-cap stocks, now preferring them over large-caps.