We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.
Sameer Dholakia says Bessemer's Anthropic Series D at $15B pre was the lowest-voted deal in firm history at the time. Byron Deeter and Sameer pushed it through, and Bessemer's empowerment culture let conviction override consensus. He wishes they had written a bigger check. That is where alpha comes from.
The highest-returning investments often face internal controversy. A sponsor's unwavering conviction, even against strong dissent (like a '1' vote for SpaceX), is the single most important factor. The sponsor forced partners to see the company firsthand to win them over.
Requiring unanimous or majority approval in investment committees leads to mediocre, mean-regressing decisions. The most controversial deals are often the best performers. A "champion model," where a single partner can push a deal through despite dissent, is more effective.
Bessemer Venture Partners publicly lists massive companies it passed on to foster a learning culture. This highlights their philosophy that the opportunity cost of missing a transformative company (a crime of omission) is far more damaging than investing in one that fails (a crime of commission).
The size of a co-investment opportunity is an underappreciated factor in its alpha potential. Large, widely syndicated deals often represent market beta, while true alpha is more frequently found in smaller deals from small- to mid-cap funds where unique value-creation opportunities are more prevalent.
Peter Thiel structured Founders Fund to avoid the mediocre, consensus-driven deals that result from partnership voting. Believing all venture profits come from a few improbable moonshots, he empowered individual partners to make unilateral, high-conviction investments. This contrarian approach allows them to back outliers that a committee would reject.
Bessemer's investment process favors individual partner conviction over group consensus. A partner can "pound the table" for a deal (the "gold nugget") without the risk of another partner vetoing it (the "blackball" model). This fosters ownership and bold bets, with performance as the ultimate accountability.
The romanticized idea of a dramatic "investment committee" meeting is a myth. The most effective investment process is collaborative and iterative, where an idea is pitched early and gains momentum across the firm over time. The formal meeting becomes a rubber stamp for a decision that has already been organically reached.
Sameer Dholakia says Bessemer's late-growth funds average 5-10% per company, but they flexed to roughly 20% in Anthropic. He argues concentration is still the goal even at $4B scale, because rare generational outcomes justify breaking the normal sizing rule when conviction is high. The fund can still be concentrated.
Sequoia's internal data shows consensus is irrelevant to investment success. A deal with strong advocates (voting '9') and strong detractors (voting '1') is preferable to one where everyone is mildly positive (a '6'). The presence of passionate conviction, even amid dissent, is the critical signal for pursuing outlier returns.
True alpha in venture capital is found at the extremes. It's either in being a "market maker" at the earliest stages by shaping a raw idea, or by writing massive, late-stage checks where few can compete. The competitive, crowded middle-stages offer less opportunity for outsized returns.