In a bull market, it's hard to tell if a GP is skilled or just lucky. A downturn reveals their true discipline regarding valuations, capital deployment speed, and how they support founders through down rounds, providing LPs with robust underwriting data.

The market's liquidity crisis is driven by a fundamental disagreement. Limited Partners (LPs) suspect that long-held assets are overvalued, while General Partners (GPs) refuse to sell at a discount, fearing it will damage their track record (IRR/MOIC) and future fundraising ability. This creates a deadlock.

When a General Partner offers a GP-led secondary, they shift the crucial decision of when to sell an asset from themselves—the expert—to the Limited Partner. This undermines a core tenet of the LP-GP relationship, as LPs lack the deep asset-level knowledge to make an informed sell-or-hold decision.

Fundrise secured stakes in top companies like Anthropic and Anduril during the 2022-2023 downturn by buying from distressed funds or filling rounds when other LPs got scared. Moments of maximum fear are when the best, otherwise inaccessible, assets become available.

General Partners (GPs) have shifted from viewing secondary sales as an LP-driven nuisance to a strategic tool. They now facilitate liquidity for investors to maintain their reputation and use continuation vehicles to retain top-performing assets beyond a fund's original lifespan.

The growth of the private credit secondary market is primarily limited by a shortage of specialized, well-capitalized buyers, not a lack of sellers. As more dedicated funds with the appropriate cost of capital enter the space, they effectively "build the market," unleashing latent supply from LPs and GPs who previously lacked a viable exit path.

The secondary market began after 2000 by buying failed corporate VC portfolios for 10-40 cents on the dollar. Today, it has completely flipped; sellers are healthy, and transactions are typically done at a gain, not a loss, making it a core liquidity path.

With fund lifecycles stretching well beyond the traditional 10 years, LPs are increasingly seeking liquidity through secondary sales. This trend isn't just a sign of pressure but a necessary market evolution to manage illiquid, long-duration assets.

GPs are caught between two conflicting goals. They can hold assets longer, hoping valuations rise to meet their paper marks and maximize returns. Or, they can sell now at a potential discount to satisfy LPs' urgent need for liquidity, thereby securing goodwill for future fundraises. This tension defines the current market.