Ashby Monk argues the US retirement system fails by offloading complex financial decisions onto individuals without adequate guidance, akin to expecting a patient to become their own doctor using a flawed online tool.
Generic financial advice often fails because it ignores an individual's specific circumstances. A better approach, similar to medicine, is to tailor strategies to a person's net worth. Someone with under $10k needs different advice than someone with over $1M, just as a morbidly obese person needs a different fitness plan than an athlete.
Many people set up automated contributions to their 401(k) or IRA but fail the crucial second step: choosing an investment. Their money then sits idle in a low-yield money market fund, earning almost nothing and negating decades of potential compound growth.
Companies now auto-enroll employees in 401(k)s at a low 3% savings rate. While seemingly helpful, this is a trap. The rate is insufficient for retirement and gives employees a false sense of security, preventing them from saving the truly necessary 12-14%.
Patients with complex illnesses often become "medical nomads," shuffling between specialists who only view problems through their narrow training lens. Effective treatment requires a coordinated, team-based approach, which is largely absent in private practice, leaving patients to manage their own care.
Medicine excels at following standardized algorithms for acute issues like heart attacks but struggles with complex, multifactorial illnesses that lack a clear diagnostic path. This systemic design, not just individual doctors, is why complex patients often feel lost.
The financial industry systematically funnels average investors into index funds not just for efficiency, but from a belief that 'mom and pop savers are considered too stupid to handle their own money.' This creates a system where the wealthy receive personalized stock advice and white-glove treatment, while smaller investors get a generic, low-effort solution that limits their potential wealth.
Many professionals endure decades of grueling work for a future reward (e.g., traveling in retirement) that is actually accessible now for a fraction of the cost and time. This highlights a fundamental flaw in the traditional 'slave-save-retire' career path.
The standard 401(k) is filled with daily-liquid assets, despite having a time horizon of decades. This structural mismatch unnecessarily limits potential returns. This is the core argument for allowing more access to less-liquid private market investments within retirement plans.
The most common financial mistakes happen not from bad advice, but from applying good advice that is mismatched with your individual personality and goals. Finance is an art of self-awareness, not a universal science where one strategy fits all. The optimal path for someone else could be disastrous for you.
The financial system is made intentionally complex not by accident, but as a method of control. This complexity prevents the average person from understanding how the system is rigged against them, making them easier to manipulate and ensuring they won't take action to protect their own interests.