Testing of Coca-Cola's AI ad revealed an inverse relationship between age and acceptance. While older audiences scored it highly, Gen Z viewers were put off, scoring it poorly. This suggests the generation most fluent in technology may value authenticity and human craft more in advertising.
Related Insights
The proliferation of AI-generated content has eroded consumer trust to a new low. People increasingly assume that what they see is not real, creating a significant hurdle for authentic brands that must now work harder than ever to prove their genuineness and cut through the skepticism.
The generation most immersed in digital life is developing a powerful nostalgia for a pre-internet world they've only seen in media. This drives trends like 'digital defiance' and an appreciation for analog products. Brands can tap into this by offering experiences that feel authentic and non-digital.
While businesses are rapidly adopting AI for content creation and communication, Gen Z consumers have a strong aversion to anything that feels artificial or inauthentic. If this demographic can detect AI-generated content in sales or marketing, they are likely to ignore it, posing a significant challenge for brands targeting them.
While Gen Z is overrepresented in ads, data shows that when they see themselves portrayed, ad effectiveness scores drop significantly. Common stereotypes of being tech-obsessed, awkward, or only in competitive situations alienate them. Intergenerational stories and portrayals of kindness perform better.
AI is primarily a cost-saving tool, not a substitute for nuanced creative direction. Furthermore, a cultural backlash is emerging among younger consumers on social media who perceive AI content as inauthentic, actively criticizing brands like MrBeast and Liquid Death for using it.
As AI generates vast amounts of generic content, brands that showcase genuine human stories, empathy, and creativity will build stronger connections and trust that technology cannot replicate.
While media coverage suggests public disdain for AI-generated ads, Coca-Cola's consumer data shows high approval scores. This highlights a critical gap between the sentiment of a threatened media industry and actual consumer behavior, suggesting audiences care more about the final product than its AI origin.
As AI makes creating complex visuals trivial, audiences will become skeptical of content like surrealist photos or polished B-roll. They will increasingly assume it is AI-generated rather than the result of human skill, leading to lower trust and engagement.
While AI video tools can generate visually interesting ads cheaply and capture views, they currently lack the authentic creative spark needed for true brand building. Their value lies in quick, low-cost content, making them a performance marketing tool rather than an asset for creating a lasting, memorable brand identity.
As AI-generated content becomes commoditized, brands can differentiate by pledging authenticity. American Eagle's viral anti-AI post shows that a "digitally organic" approach—committing to real, un-retouched, human-centric content—resonates with consumers in the same way the organic food movement created a premium category for natural products.