Banks started in the 80s and 90s are led by founders nearing retirement. With no new generation of talent eager to run small, three-branch banks, these institutions are increasingly looking for an exit. This succession problem is a primary driver of M&A activity in the sector.
Related Insights
Instead of slowly competing against local driving schools with decades of history, Coastline Academy acquires them. This strategy provides an exit for retiring owners and allows the acquirer to instantly absorb a loyal, multi-generational customer base and its associated brand trust.
Entrepreneurs who thrived during past downturns (like 2008) often become complacent. With higher overhead and a more comfortable lifestyle, they are less willing to do the hard, uncomfortable work required to win in a new down market, creating an opportunity for hungrier competitors.
Despite clear bullish signals like deregulation and a capital markets recovery, investors have hesitated to commit to financials, creating an under-owned sector. This sets the stage for a potential 'catch-up' trade, especially for regional banks positioned to regain market share.
Success in community bank investing doesn't require complex esoteric analysis. It boils down to four key metrics: high capital levels (equity-to-assets), low non-performing assets (under 2%), stable or growing book value, and a low price-to-tangible book value (under 85%).
The seed investing landscape isn't just expanding; it's actively replacing its previous generation. Legacy boutique seed firms are being squeezed by large multistage funds and new emerging managers, implying a VC's relevance has a 10-15 year cycle before a new cohort takes over.
Unlike startups, institutions like CPPIB that must endure for 75+ years need to be the "exact opposite of a founder culture." The focus is on institutionalizing processes so the organization operates independently of any single individual, ensuring stability and succession over many generations of leadership.
The concept of 'banking deserts' extends beyond underserved regions. When specialized banks like SVB disappear, entire industry verticals (like tech, agriculture, or wine) can become 'underbanked.' This creates a vacuum in specialized credit and financial services that larger, generalist banks may not fill, thus stifling innovation in specific economic sectors.
The career arcs of venture and buyout investors differ starkly. VCs rely on networks relevant to young founders, leading some to retire by 45 as connections become stale. In contrast, buyout investing is an apprenticeship business where age and experience are increasingly valued.
The narrative that young, tech-savvy customers will abandon local banks is flawed. As long as community banks can provide competitive digital services and remove the need for physical branch visits, they can retain this demographic. Stickiness is a function of convenience, not just brand.
For legacy companies in declining industries, a massive, 'bet the ranch' acquisition is not an offensive growth strategy but a defensive, existential one. The primary motivation is to gain scale and avoid becoming the smallest, most vulnerable player in a consolidating market, even if it requires stretching financially.
