Instead of focusing on grand projects that yielded little return, The Atlantic's subscription growth was driven by a culture of data science and iterative testing. They ran over 230 A/B tests in a single year on their paywall, proving that small, continuous improvements can create massive results.
Related Insights
A sophisticated paywall's goal isn't just to block content; it's to intelligently guess a user's likelihood to subscribe. If they won't subscribe, let them read to build brand. If they will, present the paywall. This guess is based on referral source, story type, and other user data to optimize both reach and revenue.
Viral growth isn't luck; it's an iterative process. When a piece of content shows even minor success, immediately abandon your content plan and create a variation on the winning theme. This business-like A/B testing approach magnifies momentum and systematically builds towards parabolic growth.
Most media companies operate on creative instinct. A more effective model is to treat content and audience growth like a financial portfolio, obsessing over data to predict outcomes and drive decisions. This brings quantitative discipline to a traditionally qualitative field.
Instead of a hard paywall after a few paragraphs, providing half of every paid article for free delivers substantial value. This strategy builds trust and keeps free subscribers engaged for months or years, eventually converting them when a particularly relevant article finally convinces them to pay.
Don't let the importance of a piece of content, like a sponsored newsletter, lead to analysis paralysis. It's better to ship consistently and learn from each deployment. This agile approach of weekly "at bats" allows for constant calibration based on real audience feedback.
Chess.com's goal of 1,000 experiments isn't about the number. It’s a forcing function to expose systemic blockers and drive conversations about what's truly needed to increase velocity, like no-code tools and empowering non-product teams to test ideas.
The sports disruptors test 10-15 new promotions at every single game. While most teams repeat a few proven successes, the Bananas embrace constant, small-scale failure as a deliberate strategy. This allows them to out-learn their competition and innovate entertainment experiences for fans at a much faster rate.
Escape Collective switched from a metered to a hard paywall because the former obscured crucial data. With users bypassing the meter in incognito mode, it was impossible to know which articles converted subscribers. A hard paywall provided clean data, sacrificing reach for clarity.
Their success isn't from brilliant ideas, but from a massive volume of experiments. By trying dozens of new promotions and social media posts weekly, they accept a high failure rate to learn faster than any competitor. This contrasts with the typical corporate playbook of repeating safe, proven tactics.
The search for a single, game-changing feature is often a myth. As demonstrated by Twitter/X's recent growth, true momentum comes from the cumulative effect of hundreds of small, iterative improvements. Success is an aggregation of marginal gains, not a single home run.
