Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Measuring the S&P 500 against the price of gold, rather than in U.S. dollars, reveals that equities remain significantly below their dot-com bubble highs. This reframes the valuation debate, suggesting stocks are not as expensive as they seem and serve as a hedge against long-term currency debasement.

Related Insights

A 100-year chart of the S&P 500 priced in gold shows a major cyclical peak was hit in late 2021, similar to 1929 and 2000. This inflection point suggests a long-term, decade-plus trend reversal favoring hard assets like gold and Bitcoin over U.S. equities.

Different valuation models tell conflicting stories about the US market. The Shiller CAPE ratio suggests extreme overvaluation near dot-com bubble highs. However, a reverse DCF model calculating the implied equity risk premium shows the market is only moderately valued, creating a confusing picture for investors.

While stock markets appear to be reaching all-time highs in dollar terms, this is an illusion created by currency devaluation. When the S&P 500's value is measured in a stable asset like gold, it has actually declined since the pre-COVID era. This reveals that gains are not from value creation but from a weaker dollar.

This simple ratio serves as a powerful, real-time indicator of market confidence in productive economic growth versus a flight to safety. A rising ratio, driven by a stronger S&P 500 or falling gold prices, signals that investors believe in the current economic strategy's ultimate success.

While the S&P 500's price-to-earnings ratio is near dot-com bubble highs, the quality of its constituent companies has significantly improved. Current companies are more profitable and generate nearly three times more free cash flow than in 2000, providing some justification for today's rich valuations.

A "Goldilocks" scenario of steady growth and disinflation could propel the S&P 500 to 8,000 by early 2026. This isn't a bubble prediction; rather, the market's structural shift to higher-margin tech companies means such a level would represent fair value, not dangerous overvaluation.

Despite its reputation, gold is not a reliable strategic inflation hedge, working only about 50% of the time. In contrast, U.S. equities have historically provided a 100% effective hedge against inflation over the long run, making them a superior asset class for preserving purchasing power in a diversified portfolio.

The argument against a market top is that high multiples are justified. In an era of sustained currency debasement, investors must hold assets like stocks to preserve purchasing power. This historical precedent suggests today's valuations might be a new, structurally higher baseline.

A long-term chart pricing the S&P 500 in gold indicates that US financial assets peaked in 2022. This signals the start of a 10-15 year cycle where hard assets like gold, commodities, and emerging market equities are poised to outperform US stocks.

Investors often fixate on nominal returns relative to the dollar. However, the true measure of wealth is purchasing power. A 10% gain in the stock market is actually a net loss if inflation causes your living costs to rise by 20%, or if other assets like gold appreciate faster.