Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Daniel Murray says Google’s latest spam update flags sites that publish hundreds of low-quality AI-written or repurposed articles and spammy backlinks. He argues a few strong, repurposed pieces with thought leadership and stats beat mass keyword articles, so marketers should audit how they use AI before scaling output.

Related Insights

The temptation to programmatically generate hundreds of pages for search is a trap. While technically possible, this content will be generic and lack the real examples, data, and trade-offs that signal authority. AI Answer Engines won't cite this content because it adds nothing new to the conversation.

Pangram Labs estimates that 40% of internet pages are AI-generated. This is largely driven by the SEO industry, which has switched to AI to produce keyword-targeted articles for pennies, flooding search results and platforms like Medium with low-cost, low-value content.

Google's search team frames the problem of low-quality, AI-generated content as a continuation of its decades-long battle against spam. The focus remains on their core competency: ranking algorithms that surface quality and demote spam, whether human- or machine-generated.

Generative AI has neutralized content volume as a competitive advantage. In fact, inconsistent messaging across many assets can penalize a brand in AI models. This reverses the old SEO playbook, making it critical to focus on fewer, higher-quality pieces with deep expertise and a consistent narrative across all channels.

Using AI to generate large volumes of content is a trap. Instead of increasing visibility, it adds to the noise of generic, forgettable information, effectively burying your brand. Customers are already learning to recognize and ignore low-effort, AI-generated content, which can ultimately harm your brand's reputation.

The initial AI threat to affiliate sites wasn't chatbots, but tools like Jasper AI. Competitors used them to flood Google with low-quality, AI-generated articles. This prompted broad Google algorithm updates that penalized many review sites, including legitimate ones.

SEO expert Gitano DiNardi warns against using AI to simply pump out generic articles like "what is a tech stack?". This creates a "race to the bottom." The strategic use of AI is to enhance subject matter expertise and create highly specific, bottom-of-funnel content that actually gets found in search.

The fear of an 'AI penalty' is misplaced. Google's guidelines target low-quality, unhelpful, and spammy content, regardless of its origin. Sophisticated, multi-agent AI systems that use real-time data and multiple knowledge bases can produce high-quality content that ranks well, unlike content from simple conversational AI tools.

Brands applying traditional SEO best practices to Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) will fail. LLMs understand semantic meaning, making keyword stuffing obsolete. Similarly, they weigh source authority and consistency over raw backlink volume, invalidating old link-building schemes.

With 47% of buyers trusting online resources less post-AI, flooding the market with low-substance, AI-generated content is a failing strategy. AI-written content that sounds plausible but lacks depth actively erodes brand credibility. Human judgment to edit, verify, and add substance is now a critical step to prevent brand damage.