With passive investing dominating and market-wide flows unreliable, investors can no longer wait for multiple expansion. The best small-cap investments are companies actively closing their own valuation gaps through significant buybacks, strategic M&A, or other aggressive, shareholder-aligned capital allocation.
Related Insights
Capital has become commoditized with thousands of PE firms competing. The old model of buying low and selling high with minor tweaks no longer works. True value creation has shifted to hands-on operational improvements that drive long-term growth, a skill many investors lack.
Identifying a stock trading below its intrinsic value is only the first step. To avoid "value traps" (stocks that stay cheap forever), investors must also identify a specific catalyst that will unlock its value over a reasonable timeframe, typically 2-4 years.
Wagner's strategy shifted from buying statistically cheap companies to requiring a clear catalyst for value realization. He found that without a catalyst, even correctly underwritten cheap stocks would continue to decline due to factors like technological disruption, making the old "cigar butt" approach obsolete.
Mark Ein's investment model focuses on finding fantastic existing companies that have plateaued. He then applies a venture-style growth mindset to accelerate their trajectory, combining the stability of an established business with the rapid-scaling tactics of a startup.
Historically, small-cap companies grew earnings faster than large-caps, earning a valuation premium. Since the pandemic, this has flipped. Large-caps have seen astronomical earnings growth while small-caps have lagged, creating a rare valuation discount and a potential mean reversion opportunity for investors.
A common activist trap is 'ambulance chasing'—looking for problems to fix. ValueAct argues the correct sequence is to first identify a great company with a differentiated investment thesis. The need for influence is secondary, preventing adverse selection.
The era of generating returns through leverage and multiple expansion is over. Future success in PE will come from driving revenue growth, entering at lower multiples, and adding operational expertise, particularly in the fragmented middle market where these opportunities are more prevalent.
The best investment deals are not deeply discounted, low-quality items like "unsellable teal crocodile loafers." Instead, they are the rare, high-quality assets that seldom come on sale. For investors, the key is to have the conviction and preparedness to act decisively when these infrequent opportunities appear.
The era of constant central bank intervention has rendered traditional value investing irrelevant. Market movements are now dictated by liquidity and stimulus flows, not by fundamental analysis of a company's intrinsic value. Investors must now track the 'liquidity impulse' to succeed.
A tender offer, where a company buys a large block of its stock in a set price range, signals higher conviction than a typical buyback program. It forces management to put a stake in the ground, indicating they believe the shares are significantly undervalued at a specific price.
