Due to economic distortions from the COVID cycle and data lags from government shutdowns, the Fed is slower than normal to ease policy despite a weakening labor market. This delay has held back the typical market broadening, creating the specific backdrop needed for small caps to outperform large caps for the first time since 2021.
The Fed is behind its usual schedule for easing policy due to data delays and COVID-era distortions. This has suppressed the typical market rotation but means the eventual dovish policy will likely be stronger than expected, creating significant upside for early-cycle investments.
Historically, small-cap companies grew earnings faster than large-caps, earning a valuation premium. Since the pandemic, this has flipped. Large-caps have seen astronomical earnings growth while small-caps have lagged, creating a rare valuation discount and a potential mean reversion opportunity for investors.
The Federal Reserve bases policy on official government labor data, which lags real-time private sector data that markets already reflect. This delay causes the Fed to 'drag its feet' on necessary policy changes like rate cuts, creating a predictable tension and period of volatility that astute investors can navigate.
The market is interpreting stable economic growth paired with only modest Federal Reserve rate cuts as a clear signal to maintain leadership in high-quality stocks. A broad rotation into deep cyclical and small-cap stocks is unlikely until the Fed becomes more aggressively dovish.
With the Federal Reserve signaling a market backstop, capital is flowing from concentrated large-cap tech winners into more cyclical, under-loved small-cap stocks (IWM). This support de-risks 'Main Street' sectors and signals a potential broadening of the market rally.
Investors should wait for two specific triggers before increasing small-cap stock exposure. The first is the Fed Funds rate falling below the 2-year Treasury yield. The second is a clear upturn in the relative earnings revision breadth of small-cap versus large-cap companies.
Following a dovish Fed meeting, the outperformance of small-cap stocks (IWM ETF) versus large-cap tech is the key signal of a healthy, broadening market rally. This indicates capital is flowing beyond mega-cap names into the wider economy, confirming a "game on" sentiment for risk assets.
Current market weakness, driven by a Federal Reserve that is moving too slowly, presents a strategic buying opportunity. Investors should reposition into sectors that have lagged for years, such as small/mid-cap stocks and consumer discretionary goods, as they stand to benefit most when the Fed inevitably takes more aggressive action.
Despite strong Q3 revenue surprises suggesting a recovery, the Federal Reserve's reluctance to cut rates aggressively is preventing a market expansion into smaller-cap and lower-quality cyclical stocks. The market needs a clearer dovish signal before this rotation can occur.
The market is entering an early-cycle earnings recovery, signaling a new bull market. This environment, supported by anticipated Fed rate cuts and favorable growth policies, is expected to benefit a wider range of companies beyond large-cap tech. Consequently, strategists have upgraded small-cap stocks, now preferring them over large-caps.