Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Private credit returns are taxed as ordinary income, interrupting the compounding process every period. Consequently, a 10% private credit return translates to roughly 7% in equity-equivalent terms. Investors need a 14% to 15% pre-tax yield in private credit to match an ordinary 10% equity return after taxes.

Related Insights

A flood of capital into private credit has dramatically increased competition, causing the yield spread over public markets to shrink from 3-4% to less than 1%. This compression raises serious questions about whether investors are still being adequately compensated for illiquidity risk.

The yield premium for private credit has shrunk, meaning investors are no longer adequately compensated for the additional illiquidity, concentration, and credit risk they assume. Publicly traded high-yield bonds and bank loans now offer comparable returns with better diversification and liquidity, questioning the rationale for allocating to private credit.

Contrary to marketing narratives, Acadian Asset Management's analysis finds no evidence that private credit generates higher risk-adjusted returns than public credit. Analysis of private issuers within public indices shows they are simply riskier firms with higher yields to compensate, not a source of alpha.

Federal taxes took roughly 160 to 170 basis points per year from taxable US equity returns over the last 30 years. Compounded over three decades, this drag eliminates approximately 36% of a portfolio's terminal value. Historically, this modern period represents a relatively low tax environment compared to prior decades.

While the US private credit market is saturated, Europe's middle-market offers higher spreads (north of 600 basis points) and lower leverage. This opportunity is most pronounced in non-sponsor deals, a segment where large banks and public markets are less active, creating a lucrative niche.

The median private credit fund now takes about 10 years to reach a DPI (Distributed to Paid-in Capital) of 1x, meaning investors wait a decade just to get their original investment back. This extended duration, longer than initially projected, is a primary catalyst for the growth of the secondary market as LPs seek earlier liquidity.

The private credit market has seen little difference in returns between managers in recent years. However, a changing economic environment is expected to create significant dispersion, where managers with superior credit selection and origination capabilities will pull away from the pack.

Private credit investments often have exposure to companies that behave like equity during downturns. However, they lack the significant upside potential of an equity position. Baylor's CIO believes this creates a poor risk-reward trade-off and prefers direct equity exposure instead.

High-yield returns on investment-grade private credit are not paid by the borrowing company on the entire loan. Lenders generate these returns by selling the low-risk senior debt and retaining a small, highly-levered 'first loss residual' tranche, which offers mid-teens returns for a credit-like risk profile.

PGIM argues that the true alpha in direct lending isn't just from the illiquidity premium. It's also generated through manager selection, strong covenants that allow for repricing risk if performance falters, and a disciplined focus on loss avoidance, which compounds returns over time.