Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

The supplement brand IM8 increased its paid marketing spend from $17M to $33M per quarter. Counterintuitively, its customer acquisition cost (CAC) dropped from $305 to $301, and then to $239. This efficiency at scale is attributed to a massive and constant refresh of diverse creative assets, which continually provides new winning signals for Meta's algorithm.

Related Insights

Stop spending money to test ads. Instead, publish a high volume of organic social content and identify what naturally gains traction. Then, convert only those proven, high-performing pieces into paid ads. This model dramatically lowers customer acquisition costs by ensuring ad spend only scales winners.

Due to algorithm changes like Meta's "Andromeda," the ad creative itself dictates targeting. To effectively spend $100K on Meta, a company needs a constant stream of 400-500 new creatives per month to avoid plateauing and being outcompeted.

A low Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) might seem successful, but it could be hiding inefficient creative. Optimizing creative strategy could dramatically lower CAC further (e.g., from $39 to $16), unlocking greater profitability and scale, especially as you increase ad spend.

Effective scaling isn't just increasing your budget. Use the 'Twin Engine' method: simultaneously increase spend (vertical scaling) while also launching new creative iterations based on top performers (horizontal scaling). This maintains efficiency and prevents ad fatigue.

While most of IM8's creative is produced in-house, they strategically partner with external agencies to maintain diversity. This practice prevents the internal team from developing a single, repetitive style. By constantly feeding different creative approaches into Meta's algorithm, they avoid performance plateaus and ensure continued growth.

While it's tempting to double down on a successful creative format, this leads to rising acquisition costs. The algorithm requires diversity. Constantly creating net-new, varied, and even "weird" ideas across different ages, genders, and settings is essential for sustained performance.

IM8 spends over $300k daily on Meta by focusing on a massive creative pipeline (testing 500-800 creators weekly) rather than complex ad-buying tactics. They view modern ad platforms as handling the targeting, making creative diversity the primary lever for growth and efficiency.

IM8 attributes its ability to scale ad spend while keeping CAC flat to its investment in over 150 offline events. These events, featuring ambassadors and scientific advisors, build significant brand trust and credibility. This offline equity directly translates to improved performance and efficiency for their online paid advertising on platforms like Meta.

In mature ad markets, creative quality is the biggest variable for success, not media spend. High-performing companies now shift budget away from platforms like Meta and Google and reinvest it into producing more content. This superior creative makes the remaining, smaller media spend far more effective.

IM8 ran over 200 offline events, a counterintuitive strategy for a digital-first brand. They believe these in-person touchpoints built significant brand trust, which directly contributed to their customer acquisition cost (CAC) decreasing even as they doubled ad spend.