Paralympian Amy Purdy tested advanced bionic ankles but reverted to simpler prosthetics for snowboarding. The high-tech feet were unpredictable, and she found that direct, predictable control over a simpler tool was more effective for a high-stakes sport.
Related Insights
In a counterintuitive medical choice, some individuals with healthy but underperforming limbs (e.g., a twisted foot) fight to have them amputated. They recognize that a well-designed modern prosthetic can provide more mobility and a better quality of life than their natural, but chronically dysfunctional, anatomy.
The Wright brothers' first plane required a 'full-body activity' to fly, with hip movements controlling wing tilt and a lever for pitch—a system compared to 'patting your head and rubbing your stomach.' The invention of the single joystick radically simplified this complex, non-intuitive interface, consolidating multi-axis control into one hand.
A severe physical limitation can be an unexpected catalyst for growth. Boris Cherny, after breaking both arms, was forced to find languages with fewer keystrokes. This led him to discover the power and efficiency of functional programming, fundamentally improving his coding approach.
The simplicity of the Limitless pendant isn't just a design choice; it's the outcome of intense customer focus. This helps avoid the 'ivory tower' trap where smart teams build complex products in isolation—a likely cause for competitors' failures. Prioritizing user feedback is key to building something that matters.
After a difficult first attempt to snowboard with prosthetics, Amy Purdy avoided despair by analyzing the failure mechanically. She identified specific, solvable problems—ankle movement and leg attachment—turning emotion into an engineering challenge.
Neuralink's initial BCI cursor used color to indicate click probability. As users' control improved, the design evolved to a reticle that uses motion and scale for feedback. This change was more effective because the human eye is more sensitive to motion than color, and it better supported advanced interactions.
Creating feature "modes" (e.g., "uphill mode") instead of exposing core mechanics (e.g., gears) creates a "nightmare bicycle." It prevents users from developing a general framework, limiting their ability to handle novel situations or repair the system.
By designing a high-performance basketball shoe for an athlete with cerebral palsy, Nike solved for the most challenging use case. This "highest order of need" approach creates a superior, non-token solution that ultimately benefits a broader audience with similar, less-extreme needs.
The dual-stick controller design has been functionally stable for nearly three decades, suggesting it is a 'peak interface' for 3D navigation. This reliability and widespread familiarity are precisely what allowed for its adoption in high-stakes fields like remote surgery and military operations, as the interface itself was a solved problem.
Contrary to popular belief, simple isn't always better. On Running's CPO argues that overly simple products give consumers fewer opportunities to explore, learn, and feel like an expert. A degree of complexity allows users to "give it its own life," which can be a more powerful driver of adoption than a streamlined experience.
