Stack Overflow, a valuable developer community, declined after its knowledge was ingested by ChatGPT. This disincentivized human interaction, killing the community and stopping the creation of new knowledge for AI to train on—a self-defeating cycle for both humans and AI.

Related Insights

Wisdom emerges from the contrast of diverse viewpoints. If future generations are educated by a few dominant AI models, they will all learn from the same worldview. This intellectual monoculture could stifle the fringe thinking and unique perspectives that have historically driven breakthroughs.

Counterintuitively, ChatGPT's launch first caused a surge in activity on Stack Overflow. Users leveraged the AI to rapidly generate and post answers, attempting to "game the system." This spike was short-lived as the community quickly identified and banned the low-quality, AI-generated content.

Tools that automate community engagement create a feedback loop where AI generates content and then other AI comments on it. This erodes the human value of online communities, leading to a dystopian 'dead internet' scenario where real users disengage completely.

By replacing junior roles, AI eliminates the primary training ground for the next generation of experts. This creates a paradox: the very models that need expert data to improve are simultaneously destroying the mechanism that produces those experts, creating a future data bottleneck.

As AI-powered search reduces referral traffic, the incentive for creating public content diminishes. This could accelerate a trend already seen with the "Twitter exodus," where users retreat from the open internet into more private communities like Discord, fragmenting public discourse.

Internal surveys highlight a critical paradox in AI adoption: while over 80% of Stack Overflow's developer community uses or plans to use AI, only 29% trust its output. This significant "trust gap" explains persistent user skepticism and creates a market opportunity for verified, human-curated data.

The most dangerous long-term impact of AI is not economic unemployment, but the stripping away of human meaning and purpose. As AI masters every valuable skill, it will disrupt the core human algorithm of contributing to the group, leading to a collective psychological crisis and societal decay.

The success of AI is creating a long-term data scarcity problem. By obviating the need for human-curated knowledge platforms like Stack Overflow, AI is eliminating the very sources of high-quality, structured data required for training future models. This creates a self-defeating cycle where AI's utility today undermines its improvement tomorrow.

After achieving broad adoption of agentic coding, the new challenge becomes managing the downsides. Increased code generation leads to lower quality, rushed reviews, and a knowledge gap as team members struggle to keep up with the rapidly changing codebase.

The decline in traffic to Stack Overflow was not uniform. The CEO notes that AI effectively answered simple, common questions, causing that segment to drop. However, the volume of complex, thorny problems requiring human expertise has remained stable, defining the platform's new core value.

AI Can Destroy the Human Communities It Learns From, a Lesson from Stack Overflow | RiffOn