In an interest rate-driven cycle, the housing market feels the impact first. Historically, an 8% drawdown in residential construction payrolls precedes a broader recession. The absence of this drawdown, due to labor hoarding by builders, is a key reason the US economy has remained resilient.

Related Insights

Companies have already pulled all available levers to manage costs short of layoffs, including halting hiring, cutting hours, and reducing temporary staff. Therefore, the persistently low layoff rate is the last defense holding the economy back from a recession. Any significant increase in layoffs would signal this firewall has broken.

The podcast's economists assess the probability of a recession in the next year at 40-45%, significantly higher than the consensus view of 25-30%. This heightened risk is based on deteriorating labor market trends and is corroborated by Moody's own machine learning models.

The job growth diffusion index, measuring the share of industries expanding payrolls, fell to 47.6 in October. A reading below 50 has historically signaled a recession, indicating that current job gains are dangerously concentrated in just a few sectors like healthcare.

The current labor market is characterized by both low hiring and low firing rates. While this appears stable, it makes the economy fragile and more vulnerable to negative shocks. Unlike a high-churn environment, there is little buffer to absorb a sudden downturn, increasing the risk of a rapid deterioration.

In a machine learning algorithm designed by Moody's to predict recessions, aggregate building permits (single-family and multifamily) emerged as the single most important variable. A decline in permits is a powerful signal of elevated recession risk for the entire economy.

Contrary to most industries that see technological gains, housing construction has become less efficient. This stagnation is a key, often overlooked driver of housing affordability issues, as the fundamental cost to build has not decreased with technology.

Contrary to the consensus view, Crossmark's Victoria Fernandez is concerned about resurgent inflation. She points to recent increases in housing price reports, noting they typically lead rental price increases by about six months, signaling future pressure on a key inflation component that the Fed may be ignoring.

A key reason the U.S. avoided a recession is its mortgage structure. With 64% of U.S. mortgages fixed at 3.5% or lower, consumers were shielded from rate hikes that crippled European households, where over 80% of mortgages are floating-rate, thereby sustaining consumer spending.

Three-quarters of US household wealth is in homes. BlackRock's Rick Reeder argues that a healthy housing market is critical for the broader economy, as it unlocks labor mobility (allowing people to move for jobs) and creates construction jobs. Lower mortgage rates are key to stimulating this velocity.

Recent data paints a conflicting picture. While forward-looking indicators for housing and the job market point to a softening economy, inflation metrics like the Producer Price Index (PPI) remain stubbornly high. This combination suggests a move toward a stagflationary environment.