The government paying over a billion dollars to dead people is not just fraud; it's a symptom of profound operational failure. The inability of the Social Security Administration and the Treasury to share a simple "death master file" points to a systemic breakdown in data management and accountability.

Related Insights

A bureaucracy can function like a tumor. It disguises itself from the "immune system" of public accountability by using noble language ("it's for the kids"). It then redirects resources (funding) to ensure its own growth, even if it's harming the larger organism of society.

The government's standard procedure is to disburse funds and attempt to recover improper payments later—a highly inefficient process that costs hundreds of billions annually. A more effective system would require real-time prepayment verification, defaulting to "no pay" if eligibility cannot be confirmed, preventing fraud before it occurs.

Government programs often persist despite failure because their complexity is a feature, not a bug. This system prevents average citizens, who are too busy with their lives, from deciphering the waste and holding the "political industrial complex" accountable, thereby benefiting those in power.

Instead of officially defaulting on unpayable promises like Social Security, governments opt for massive inflation. This devalues the currency so severely that while citizens receive their checks, the money's purchasing power is destroyed, rendering the benefits worthless without an explicit, unpopular cut.

Since the SSA database is a single point of failure for federal payments, its rampant inaccuracies must be addressed with a one-time, all-hands cleanup. This involves reconciling records across the VA, IRS, and state death registries, then maintaining integrity with a publicly tracked "accuracy scorecard" to ensure permanent data hygiene.

The city wasn't simply bad at accounting; it effectively had no centralized system. Finances were tracked on scraps of paper and in drawers, making it impossible to know the true state of its debt. This systemic failure, not just policy choices, made the collapse inevitable.

The massive fraud in Minnesota is framed not as mere incompetence but as a deliberate political machine. By allowing entities to siphon billions, politicians secure a loyal voting bloc and campaign donations. The fraud becomes a feature, not a bug, of a self-perpetuating system where accountability is discouraged.

A significant source of waste stems from "zombie payments"—recurring government funds that continue indefinitely without review. When the official who authorized the payment leaves, retires, or dies, there is often no system to shut it off, creating a perpetual drain of funds to companies or individuals who rarely report it.

Flawed Social Security data (e.g., listing deceased individuals as alive) is used to fraudulently access a wide range of other federal benefits like student loans and unemployment. The SSA database acts as a single point of failure for the entire government ecosystem, enabling what Elon Musk calls "bank shot" fraud.

While most local government data is legally public, its accessibility is hampered by poor quality. Data is often trapped in outdated systems and is full of cumulative human errors, making it useless without extensive cleaning.

Payments to Deceased People Reveal Systemic Government Incompetence | RiffOn