Don't bet on a single creator. Contact 100+, test the 10 most underpriced, and identify the 2-3 "winners" who drive 80% of revenue. Move these winners to a monthly retainer and repeat the process, systematically building an army of ROI-positive promoters.
Requesting a 3-video package builds audience familiarity better than a one-off video. More importantly, the ongoing affiliate commission creates a financial relationship that discourages creators from raising their prices or accepting exclusive deals from competitors.
Creator agencies and networks price talent efficiently. The real opportunity is in mass outreach to smaller creators (10k-50k subs) who don't know their market value. A fraction will underprice themselves so dramatically that they become a marketing arbitrage opportunity.
The strategy scales from individual sponsored videos to having 100+ creators on retainer posting monthly. This creates an "astro turf" of content that dominates the niche's ecosystem. A successful video can then go viral, prompting other creators to organically make videos about your product to capture views.
While TikTok and Reels generate awareness, their ROI is hard to track as users often Google the product after seeing a video. Long-form YouTube videos with affiliate links in the description provide a direct, trackable dollar amount for every conversion, proving the value of each creator relationship.