Spanier warns that in an AI-first world, other departments can make their own marketing assets, so CMOs who only run campaigns risk being relegated. He points to AT&T's Kellen Smith-Kenny and J.P. Morgan's Carla Hassan as CMOs running product and compliance councils and leading the growth conversation.
Spanier cites YouTube creators Colin and Samir, who told him brands need to be a character in the creator's universe rather than broadcast matching luggage. He says the best marketers today are creators because they are obsessed with audience and engagement, something large marketing organizations lose.
Spanier benchmarks AI adoption on a 100-meter race: Google marketing, a really sophisticated advertiser, sits around meter 12 to 15, while most other CMOs place themselves at 5 to 10. The track is not straight, and he still says the technology just isn't there yet.
Spanier cites Rashad de Bakawala's column A versus column B framing. Column A is checklists, optimizations, updates and delegation; column B is mentoring, learning, building and growing. AI is incredibly good at column A, so CMOs should shift their time toward doing more column B.
After interviewing Gary Vaynerchuk, Spanier started posting daily watch content on YouTube and social platforms for seven months. He says every CMO should host a YouTube channel for a period to experience being on the other side of the camera and learn how the creator business actually works.
Josh Spanier says a prominent CMO predicted half of 100 marketing leaders would be fired in 2026. By fall, no purge had happened. He credits a shift from 'what is AI doing to me?' to 'what can I do with AI?' and says marketing headcount rose because ideas, not resources, were the constraint.
Spanier says AI's persistent memory means marketing best practices and insights no longer vanish when employees leave. He describes the CMO as a brand systems architect who embeds learning across the process. At Chime, AI call screening raised customer satisfaction by 20 to 30 points.
