Jon Krohn says OpenAI's claimed singularity applies with a smooth external force applied from rest, so it covers official variants C and D. The unforced variants A and B remain unsolved, and many mathematicians consider those the heart of the problem; OpenAI says it will not claim the prize.
Jon Krohn says OpenAI posted 722 manuscripts, then withdrew three after a sign error broke one proof and two dependents, and revised 14 more. It told Retraction Watch about half were published without full verification; OpenAI claimed 42% Lean-formalized, while independent recounts put the figure at 24% to 36%.
Jon Krohn says a model can now generate hundreds of plausible proofs or thousands of lines of code in hours, so generation stops being the bottleneck; verification takes over. He argues the results that hold up will pair machine-checkable evidence, like Lean proofs or strong test suites, with humans who understand them.
Jon Krohn says Tristan Buckmaster and Levant Alpugi had used OpenAI products before finding related fluid blowups. OpenAI denied drawing on their unpublished work, but told The Economist it could not rule out their drafts in its training data. It later credited them and offered joint priority.
Jon Krohn says 25 Fields Medalists warned that AI company goals and mathematicians' goals are misaligned, and more than 8,000 researchers endorsed it. Their core argument: solving a problem is a means, not the end. The end is human understanding, and the long struggle toward solutions produces new tools.
