The traditional purpose of an IPO—raising capital for company growth—is obsolete. Today, companies scale using private equity and only go public to allow early investors and insiders to cash out. This means the public market captures significantly less of a company's early, high-growth phase.
Index providers are no longer neutral. By changing inclusion rules to quickly add "hot" IPOs like SpaceX, they are making active bets on specific companies. This blurs the line between active and passive investing, requiring investors to have an opinion on the index's strategy itself rather than just blindly buying.
For companies like SpaceX, Nasdaq now allows index inclusion in just 15 days (down from six months) and artificially inflates weight by treating a 5% float as 15%. This creates a massive, predictable, and forced buying event from index funds, which must sell other holdings to accommodate the new stock, distorting the market.
The market distortion from an IPO's index inclusion isn't a one-time event. As insiders' shares unlock months later, the public float increases. Nasdaq's rules will then force index funds to buy even more shares to match the new, higher float (multiplied by 3x), creating a recurring cycle of predictable, forced buying and price distortion.