Researcher Stacey Kim distinguishes malicious envy, which centers on the envied person and wanting to pull them down, from benign envy, which centers on the desired good itself. Refocusing attention from the colleague to what you want makes the feeling more motivating rather than toxic.
Researcher Stacey Kim uses the acronym SIREN: similar target, intangible desire, relevant comparison, and negative emotion. She says breaking envy into those four parts helps reveal what you want, why that domain matters, and how strongly you should really pay attention to the career signal.
Researcher Stacey Kim says the tangible prize—promotion, money, vacation—is not usually the real desire at all. She asks people to imagine how getting it would feel, because the intangible feeling, like financial security or mentoring others, is what they actually want to capture.
Researcher Stacey Kim says guilt can often morph into shame, the belief that “I’m a bad person,” and shame makes people freeze. She cites high-achieving coaching clients who envy a colleague’s promotion, then feel really hopeless and stuck—what philosopher Sara Protasi calls inert envy.
Kim cites Princeton professor emeritus Susan Fisk, who avoided putting two people at the same level on a research project. Fisk mixed people at different stages or with different skills, Kim says, because envy often targets similar peers and collaboration improves when competition is reduced.
Researcher Stacey Kim describes how Korea used collective envy and resentment of Japan to mobilize national improvement, competing for the 1988 Olympics and in cars and electronics. She says that kind of collective envy can be channeled into productive competition rather than left as frustration.
Researcher Stacey Kim contrasts a primary response—watching an envied basketball player, practicing dribbling and shooting to improve—with secondary responses like gossiping, invoking a “genius effect,” or giving up. She says primary responses are more useful because they actually pursue the desired skill directly.