Colonia Therapeutics' CEO argues that lentiviral delivery is ideal for oncology's required long-term persistence, while LNP delivery is better suited for autoimmune indications needing transient, multi-dose responses. This frames them as complementary technologies for different therapeutic "swim lanes" rather than as direct rivals in a zero-sum game.

Create's strategy is not limited to a single cell type. They view success in solid tumors as requiring the programming of all immune cells. Their platform can specifically engineer myeloid cells, T-cells, and NK cells in vivo, orchestrating a coordinated, multi-pronged attack on cancer.

Instead of focusing solely on T-cells, Create's platform first targets myeloid cells, which constitute up to 60% of some solid tumors. Programming these cells transforms the tumor microenvironment, enabling a 5-10x influx of CD8 T-cells. This overcomes a key barrier for T-cell therapies in solid tumors.

Despite exciting early efficacy data for in vivo CAR-T therapies, the modality's future hinges on the critical unanswered question of durability. How long the therapeutic effects last, for which there is little data, will ultimately determine its clinical viability and applications in cancer versus autoimmune diseases.

While personalized cancer vaccines require extracting and processing a patient's tumor, Create Medicines' in vivo approach is entirely off-the-shelf. By delivering the programming directly into the body, they enable the patient's own immune system to do the complex, personalized work of attacking the cancer itself.

The commercial advantage of one-time CRISPR/Cas9 therapies is shrinking. Advancements in RNA modalities like siRNA now offer durable, long-lasting effects with a potentially safer profile. This creates a challenging risk-reward calculation for permanent gene edits in diseases where both technologies are applicable, especially as investor sentiment sours on CRISPR's long-term safety.

Early data from an in vivo CAR-T therapy suggests a paradigm shift is possible. By engineering T-cells directly inside the patient with a simple infusion, this approach could eliminate the need for leukapheresis and external manufacturing, completely disrupting the current cell therapy model.

While complex gene editing may be challenging in vivo, Colonia's platform presents a novel opportunity: targeting different immune cell types (e.g., T-cells and NK cells) with distinct payloads in a single treatment. This could create synergistic, multi-pronged attacks on tumors, a paradigm distinct from current ex vivo methods which focus on engineering a single cell type.

Beyond transient RNA, Create has developed a unique retrotransposon based on the human Line-1 element. This technology allows for stable, scarless gene delivery using only RNA, providing an option for durable expression (e.g., for CD19 CAR-T) alongside their transient approaches, creating a highly versatile platform.