The 'Valinor' metaphor for AI talent's destination has flipped. It once signified leaving big labs for well-funded startups like Thinking Machines. Now, as those startups face turmoil, Valinor represents a return to the stability and immense resources of established players like OpenAI, which are re-attracting top researchers.
Contrary to the post-COVID trend of tech decentralization, the intense talent and capital requirements of AI have caused a rapid re-centralization. Silicon Valley has 'snapped back' into a hyper-concentrated hub, with nearly all significant Western AI companies originating within a small geographic radius.
The investment thesis for new AI research labs isn't solely about building a standalone business. It's a calculated bet that the elite talent will be acquired by a hyperscaler, who views a billion-dollar acquisition as leverage on their multi-billion-dollar compute spend.
Universities face a massive "brain drain" as most AI PhDs choose industry careers. Compounding this, corporate labs like Google and OpenAI produce nearly all state-of-the-art systems, causing academia to fall behind as a primary source of innovation.
The intense talent war in AI is hyper-concentrated. All major labs are competing for the same cohort of roughly 150-200 globally-known, elite researchers who are seen as capable of making fundamental breakthroughs, creating an extremely competitive and visible talent market.
A key to OpenAI's innovation is hiring young talent who grew up thinking natively about AI. These individuals "hold the model weights in their brains," enabling creative breakthroughs. The team behind the video model Sora, for instance, has a median age in the low twenties.
Top AI labs face a difficult talent problem: if they restrict employee equity liquidity, top talent leaves for higher salaries. If they provide too much liquidity, newly-wealthy researchers leave to found their own competing startups, creating a constant churn that seeds the ecosystem with new rivals.
Quora's initial engineering team was a legendary concentration of talent that later dispersed to found or lead major AI players, including Perplexity and Scale AI. This highlights how talent clusters from one generation of startups can become the founding diaspora for the next.
With partners like Microsoft and Nvidia reaching multi-trillion-dollar valuations from AI infrastructure, OpenAI is signaling a move up the stack. By aiming to build its own "AI Cloud," OpenAI plans to transition from an API provider to a full-fledged platform, directly capturing value it currently creates for others.
With model improvements showing diminishing returns and competitors like Google achieving parity, OpenAI is shifting focus to enterprise applications. The strategic battleground is moving from foundational model superiority to practical, valuable productization for businesses.
The "Valinor" metaphor for top AI talent has evolved. It once meant leaving big labs for lucrative startups. Now, as talent returns to incumbents like OpenAI with massive pay packages, "Valinor" represents the safety and resources of the established players.