Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Toto says Mercedes' push-pull DAS steering changed front-wheel toe and helped heat tires by running them inefficiently. The FIA allowed it for a year, then banned it; Toto suspects Mercedes lost the political argument because rivals said replicating it would be costly. He says a legal innovation can still lose through regulation.

Related Insights

While F1 heavily regulates physical and computational fluid dynamics (CFD) testing, there are currently no rules governing the use of AI. This regulatory gap creates a new frontier for teams to gain a competitive advantage, pushing them to explore AI for strategy and design in ways they can't with traditional methods.

Toto says Mercedes firewalls information so only 20-25 people need access, but personnel movement makes leaks inevitable. He notes UK contracts can block moves for 12 months, while Switzerland caps them at three, so hiring location affects how long secrets stay secret. Teams must plan for eventual disclosure.

Toto describes a mock trial where engineers who invented a loophole act as prosecutors and other engineers defend it. He and general counsel are judges, testing how convincing and legal the defense is before bringing the FIA into discussions early. The aim is to stress-test the argument internally before regulators see it.

Toto says his engineering side would like free rein under the cost cap, but the best engineers and infrastructure would build a car five seconds quicker. That would hurt competition, so F1 keeps adding restrictions even though engineers say it is less fun. He accepts that tradeoff as sensible for the sport.

Toto says Mercedes gave him a framework to act outside its corporate structure, letting him run the team like a 20-person organization. That ownership-backed speed differs from team principals who report to CEOs or shareholders and fear being punished for decisions. He says he cannot be fired until he badly screws up.

In Formula 1, durable success comes from operational excellence, not sustainable strategic power. Clever rule interpretations or design innovations provide only a temporary edge before rivals copy them. Long-term dominance, like Mercedes' eight-year streak, is a result of superior competency in engineering, design, and execution rather than a defensible strategic moat.

Formula 1 thumbnail

Formula 1

Acquired·9 months ago

Sports regulators tolerated Speedo's polyurethane swimsuit until it and its successors led to an "unbelievable rate" of broken records (147 in 2009 alone). The sheer velocity of improvement, which felt jarring and unnatural, prompted a complete ban, not just the initial innovation.

Speedo exploited World Aquatics' lenient definition of "fabric" to incorporate polyurethane panels into its LZR Racer swimsuit. This seemingly small loophole allowed for a game-changing product that created less drag, giving swimmers a significant advantage, and forcing the entire industry and its regulators to react.

Toto says the roughly $200m cost cap accounts for every engineering resource. Teams must choose between spending compute on a front wing needed in three months and long-term lab work, so speculative R&D largely disappears and competition tightens. He says this limits the science he loves but gives smaller teams a more equal budget.

Toto says forceful engineers who keep pushing experiments past a reasonable point are no longer part of Mercedes. The valued trait is contributing to overall lap time, not a department's target, and management stops projects once data says they should. He wants engineers to love the result, not their own idea.