Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Jim Milbury argues you cannot rank individual engineers without breaking the measurement, especially when a board sees a low-ranked engineer who spent the quarter on architecture or customer work. He and Dan Bender agree that once a number decides pay, it stops telling the truth and human judgment must remain in the loop.

Related Insights

Campbell's Law predicts that when a metric is used for high-stakes decisions like terminations, it gets manipulated. Forced ranking is a prime example, as people game the system, distorting the very performance it's supposed to measure.

By ranking engineers on AI token consumption, Meta is experiencing Goodhart's Law: "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." Employees reportedly build bots to needlessly burn tokens for status, demonstrating how gamifying a proxy metric can backfire and disconnect from actual business impact.

The mandate to sort employees into fixed buckets allows managers to legitimize their personal biases. Prejudices about who "belongs" in the bottom tier can be masked as compliance with a data-driven system, leading to disparate impacts as seen in lawsuits against companies like Ford.

When employees are ranked against each other, helping a colleague succeed can directly harm one's own rating. This creates a "collaboration tax," disincentivizing the teamwork and mutual support that are crucial for high-performing, agile teams.

Citing management theorist W. Edwards Deming, the hosts argue that the vast majority of performance variation comes from the system, not individuals. Forced ranking inverts this, creating a process to punish individuals for systemic flaws that only management can address.

Microsoft's decade-long experiment with forced ranking revealed a toxic side effect: top engineers actively refused to join teams with other high-achievers. This was a rational move to avoid being the "lowest" performer on a rockstar team, directly undermining collaboration.

Proponents claim forced ranking ensures accountability. However, managing performance and holding people accountable is a fundamental job of a manager. Relying on a quota system is an abdication of that responsibility, replacing coaching with a mechanistic process.

While peer feedback is more accurate than a manager's, directly tying numerical scores to compensation "weaponizes" the system, leading to score inflation and reciprocity. Use peer reviews for development and as one of many qualitative inputs for a manager's final compensation decision.

CJ Hess says he left hourly consulting because his output rose while his pay fell. Alex Lieberman says Tenex's highest- and lowest-paid engineers differ by roughly 4x, not 10x. The hardest compensation problem is paying engineers for architecture and client meetings, not just coding. That nuance keeps the model from being pure piecework.

The bell curve is an installed process, not a discovered reality. By mandating a fixed percentage of employees must be in the bottom tier, the system guarantees the existence of "low performers" even on a team of superstars, creating collateral damage.